
Published on 3/23/2009
Sincerely,
The Newest Member of the “I HATE Beyoncé Club”
Before you all start out trying to ring my neck, I better first state the fact that this letter should strictly be filed in a drawer set aside for anything fiction. This letter isn’t true to my situation, but I guarantee you it’s a feeling that’s continually echoed throughout the minds of many women and men out there. We’re no stranger to the fact that people across the board got love for Beyoncé, but lets keep it real since we’ve already entered the sharing circle, and dish a bit on the reasons why people got hate for Beyoncé too.
1)”You remind me of a girl that I once knew.”
Usher wasn’t playing when he sang about his bout with Déjà Vu, but if Beyoncé reminds you of someone in your past, it may not exactly be a pleasant memory. Did any of you go to school with that girl who was balancing Student Council, Track and Field and in her spare time was the head of the Cheerleading Squad, while you were merely hoping to have a chance to at least make Student of the Week? Did I forget to mention that she was also dating the captain of the football team while you were still combing through the school directory hoping to will yourself a first date? Well, Beyoncé may unconsciously remind you of that girl that you hated who with the blink of an eye had and did everything you wanted too.
2) Your man wants her.
Referring to the story within the letter of course, but also enforcing the idea that this letter mirrors so many male opinions. She has landed on many a male magazine polls on who they feel is the sexiest women alive and if that doesn’t further this simple argument, then consider this: In 2007 she became the first and only singer to grace the cover of the Sports Illustrated Swimsuit Edition.
3) Even on her worst day she’s still so damn beautiful, or is she?
Has anybody ever seen Beyoncé without her year round costume on? Of course I’m speaking lightly on the gobs of make up and hair extensions we’re so accustomed to seeing her sporting at every venue and event she attends. Sure Barbie looks good when you first take her out of the box, but after you’ve played with her for a while she loses her luster, her hair goes flat, and she becomes a bit dingy. Without all that makeup and weave, would Beyoncé still carry her torch of defining perfected beauty, or would the flame slowly die at the pluck of each individual eyelash? Just a question.
4) As if she didn’t have enough money of her own, she had to run out and marry Jay-Z, whose got plenty more to add to their ever-growing bank account.
Some people can’t even pay the rent, let alone find a decent man in life who’s willing to contribute to life’s simple and monetary household needs. Beyoncé’s estimated net worth is sitting on a comfortable $350 million; when you factor in her boo’s acquired income, the two love birds are sitting easy on a billi. Can I get some bailout money from them?
5) People constantly revere her as the best, which makes her an easy front-runner for being the most annoying artist on your Top Ten list.
She’s been nominated for more awards than she’s actually ever won, but the fact that she is faithfully considered whether or not she even produces the fruit of worth is a clear testimony to the claim that I’m making here. NAACP recently granted her a trophy for Outstanding Female Artist, leaving artists like Mariah Carey and Alicia Keys to bask in the shadows of her continual glory. If it wasn’t for a shun by The Academy, then I’d say Beyoncé was thought to be the best at everything. Good for you Jennifer Hudson.
6) She’s the reason we no longer have Destiny’s Child.
When “Beyoncé and the Girls” first stepped on the scene under their well-known alias, Destiny’s Child, it was clear for the world to see who was really headlining and who would remain in the shadows: our wonderful Queen B. Riddled with drama, rumored to be a result of a single spotlight on the ever talented Beyonce’, the group went from four to two, back to four, and then down to three and before you knew it, Beyoncé was running things on the airwaves with a flourishing solo career. Coincidence anyone?
7) She could learn to share the spotlight a little, couldn’t she?
A lot of people wish Beyoncé would take a long vacation and let some other talent break the surface of our 24 Play. Maybe have a baby with Jay Z, or continue working on her blossoming acting career. Plain and simply, maybe she just need to keep herself busy and let some other voices crack through the sound of our stereo.
8) For the men… She’s got the world wanting to Upgrade U.
Not like some of you don’t deserve the boot or need a reality check to create a higher standard, but it’s one thing to kick a cheater “to the left,” but it’s another to bring a better man into the picture to replace you.
9) Put a ring on it…
Easier said than done B. I think the ladies of the world have already thought of this. But if I was sitting easy on $350 million, I’m sure I’d be up to my ear in proposals and jumping out windows to avoid them until I had them sign my pre-nup. The anthem makes sense, but it doesn’t take into account the plight of the real single ladies of this world. If we run out and dump our men just because they didn’t pop the question in our matrimonial time frame, then we’ll be “up in the club” feeling unnecessarily lonely. Then we’ll be singing with your sister crying about the plight of T.O.N.Y. Why bother?
10) She’s a sellout.
A lot of people were deep in the fold when she rocked the mic with a passion on her solo debut Dangerously In Love. When she told us it was her B’Day, we stood in line ready to celebrate. But when she commercialized her music and offered us I am… Sasha Fierce, sure the album sold millions, possibly only off the name Beyoncé, but compared to her previous two offerings, the musical quality pales in comparison.
11) She’s overrated.
To say the least in some peoples eyes. When you put a spotlight on depth and substance, Beyonce’s catalog of music is about as sturdy as a House of Cards. Sure she’s standing on the mountaintop, looking onward at a sea of counterparts, but did she make that ascent on merit, or does the fact that she fits the criteria of what the media considers “The Total Package,” carry her past the masses and gain her a position in the top spot? From song lyrics, to originality, to embodying everything it takes to be a real X-Factor, compared to other artists like Jill Scott, Sade’ or India Arie in some people’s opinion, she doesn’t really measure up. She’s got “the look,” “the sound,” “the style,” the worlds been waiting for, right? Marketing comes down to dollars and sense, even when at times it seems to make no sense. Mathematics. Unfortunately for us, we’re not the ones formulating the equations. It’s all about the Cha- Ching.
12) The “Blacker the Berry” isn’t always the “Sweeter the Juice”.
We all know Beyoncé is a red bone, but even being that light isn’t enough to satisfy the media. In 2005, Vanity Fair denies rumors of lightening her image on the cover of their magazine, but now L’Oreal is currently under the radar for doing the same skin altering. I don’t know about you, but I love my brown skin.
13) She’s a hypocrite?
She’s a devout Methodist, raised in the church and very strong in her faith, and when speaking out about the criticism towards her raunchy clothing and behavior, she has been quoted in saying, “I honestly believe [God] wants people to celebrate their bodies so long as you don’t compromise your Christianity in the process.” Is that so. Now she’s singing about feeling her Halo and finally finding her angel in Jay Z, yet last time I checked her man was an ex drug dealer. That might be viewed as a little contradictory when you consider the good girl image she continually tries to show us.
14) Jay Z is not that attractive.
Beauty is in the eye of the beholder, but when you’re a high profile celebrity society tends to think you should be dating a handsome man like the Rock or the next LL Cool J. Beyoncé chose Jigga, who probably doesn’t stand a chance to becoming the next Mr. Universe, but because Beyoncé could have whomever she wants, people feel like they should have a say so in her love match also.
15) Jealousy.
It’s easy to make a list of all the reasons why you could possibly hate a person, but if that list comes to you a little easy, then you may want to consider the real answer: jealousy. Beyoncé’s a great artist and I think people secretly wish they could be her. But if you work on being “you,” then you won’t have time to have a reason to hate on her.
These are all just possible ideas, and not something I personally hold as doctrine. I believe you have to personally know a person to truly have a reason to hate on ‘em, and since I have yet to be invited for tea at Beyoncé’s, none of these bulletins personally reflect my opinion. Instead of focusing so much on B, you should consider a quote by Dr. Benjamin E. Mays,
“Whatever you do, do it so well that no man living, no man dead or no man yet to be born can do it any better.”
That’s the philosophy we see in Beyoncé. She does it to the best of her abilities and her talents have led her to the top of the industry. So I’ll leave you with this — don’t hate, just step up to the plate.
I did. But I was 19 when we met and um...unexperienced. We married when I was 23 after graduation. And he's also very Christian and told me...
asking about men won't do anything. we all know that men aren't held to any standards at all really when it comes to appearance. all they...
Right? These categories aren't going anywhere. Honestly, we will forever have gender expectations. I also feel it's a false myth that not...
Oh good, am glad am not the only one that thought that was a bit of an over-share.





OOps typos glaour: but I think you get me
She can’t sing all that great, kelly is better than her and prettier than her…..
Oh also
Ummm I dont hate beyonce for marrying Jay: can I call him Jay?
If their happy and in love: Let them do thier thing! Many chick hate because she marry a mega millionaire: NOT because of his looks or personality ( of which they do not know).
Let her do her damn thing: I was never jelouse of ANYONE a day in my life: THANK God for this:
I dont hate but I AM irritated with anything\anyone that is all HYPE!
Lastly
PPL stating they look up to her is hi-larious: to each their own: but it just plain stupid: How can you look up to someone you dont know?
What exactly do you looking up to them for?
Fashion inspiration?
Weaves, what?
It’s sad that ppl look up towards singer, movie stars when they have stylist, and get paid to LOOK and ACT a certain way…
Why not look up to someone whose done something for the world
I mean really…… I am afraid of my little neice seeing her light skin mother praising her daughter that her skin didnt tan, or that her hair is getting long like Beyonce or CIARA: I mean really are you a GOOD person if your light skin, or have straight indian weave hair????
What is the message were sending WOMEN: Hell not even little girl: females in general
Grown ass women look up to these fake entertainers for everything under the sun
The day an entertainer educates, clean up the enviorments, stops war, feed the hungry, and cures all diseases: that will be the day I call them an angel, or CLOSE to AMAZING UNTIL THEN:
Jump off none of these entertainers are IDOLS: such a shame for anyone to “look up to them: its sad really
The only IDOL I have is GOD….
and im not even religious: how you figure that????
Very well said, Trudat. I couldn’t agree with you more! I just love these lines that you wrote ^_^: “Why not look up to someone whose done something for the world,” “The day an entertainer educates, clean up the environment, stops war, feed the hungry, and cures all diseases: that will be the day I call them an angel, or CLOSE to AMAZING UNTIL THEN….”
Okay, I’ve seen the woman, I was out at a particular Mall and there she was walking in. I was tripped out, so shocked, thinking I was going to see someone and mean, hypocritical, and fake as has been stated in the past; not at all, she was cool, she even looked over waved and mouthed hey. let it go people, she’s doing her thing, some of us need to stop and a “thing” that we enjoy so that we can leave others alone. You never know maybe it will be a positive move instead judging and nitpicking others. Have A Great Weekend.
Look, I confused about B. I mean she supports women and all: Like the all girls band she made! But Her Sasha Fierce is making alot of seductive songs though. And #1 Fan of B. has a point in some things though.
Out of all the wonderful things in the world Beyonce could have written and sang a song about she chose to sing about DICK in the song EGO. She acts like a woman of quality and character when being interviewed and on national tv but when on stage she sings about dick corrupting vulnerable minds. I wish somebody would roll out a plastic big ass black dick on stage while she is singin EGO. America is on to the negative poor quality vibe she puts out and it shows with her record sales. Her career is in decline.
Yes I feel you. I have been listening to hip hop/music for a very long time especially Beyonce and it is a shame about the direction that music is going today. I am fed up with all the sexuality and negativity in music today. I do not understand—-out of all the wonderful things she can sing about–out of all the things in the world Beyonce could have chose to sing about–she chose to sing about penis. I was walking in a school the other day(summer school program for young kids-very young) —-and I heard a 9yr old girl walkin down the hall singin some of the words to the song ego—”it’s too big it won’t fit”—-oh my goodness! some of the go Beyonce comments I have read on this sight sends a message to people that it is ok—the reality of it is that—-it is not ok!
She is not singing about a penis smart guy…. she’s talking about her/his ego:)
However, I agree totally with the writer of this little article. I mean you were right on with almost all the reason I HATE on Beyonce and I do think that some of my reasons were justified.. Yes my man does love her, but that’s ok I have my crush to. However, I understand that Beyonce has created an illusion, she portrays as someone who really doesn’t exist, no one is that perfect. I have seen her live, yes she is beautiful–glamorous, but I know that underneath that lace weave, that touched up nose, extra addition added to the hiney, make up etc.. the real Beyonce lies beneath, yeah she may still be beautiful but at the same time she may be a dissappointment to us all. No one is that perfect, however, there are beautiful people, many many beautiful women in this world that I would love to hate on, but B is off that list, cause she’s not real. Yes she can sing, she is getting better as the years go by and she is an amazing performer, when she is not doing 200 costume changes in a single show. But, Beyonce is larger than life thanks to the media and it is sad to say I am a huge fan of her last album I am… but, I do think she sold out to us [sistas].. no offense white people, I love you guys too. But, B went from writing booty shaking, club bumping songs to all of her songs being written by white people, with the exception of broken hearted girl, which was written by Baby face. But I am done, B is going to do her thing, she is loving this attention that we are given her. I don’t want to compare her and Alicia Keys, because there is no comparison, B has more money and probably more fans and media time, but Alicia is a SOUL SISTA and so is Lauryn Hill. Anyhow they are all doing better than me.
I never have a problem with beautiful, accomplished women since I consider myself to be in their company. The only thing that would give me a problem with Beyonce or any other hot girl is if she was going for my man. Then all bets are off.
Elle-please don’t take it the wrong way but your considerring yourself in the same company or class as Beyonce who is a well accomplished beautiful woman. Beautiful and accomplished she is but it does not mean she has class or character and I am not saying you do not. What I am trying to say is I would not put yourself in the same company as her. Your talking about a woman who’s inspiration for writing some of her songs is dick. She just said not to long ago she wishes she was not black and born of Latin decent. This woman says a lot of things just to sell albums and make money which she is doing-she could care less about how her music affects the young black people today. Also this woman married an ex drug dealer. I do not feel she represents us black people well. You wonder why people are so negative toward us black people and why police racial profile us. There are so many people and Beyonce is one of them that do not represent us black people well. Please do not put yourself in the same company as her-anyone with class and character is a step above her.
I love Beyonce, I was happy a sista who is lighter(tan)color brown skinned showed u on the scene and took the industry by storm. I could totally relate to her look, I am lighter skin black girl, attractive and had to put up with a lot of crap from sista’s because of it, sometimes.
I would be friendly but, on sight they seem to hate on me or my friends who were similar looking.
As far as Beyonce taking a break, DOES MTV take a break and close down? No.Why on earth should Beyonce take a break while she’s at the top of her game? She has to cash in now make the money while she can.
Look what happned when Whitney took a break? Will she ever come back to that echelon again, probably not.
Then Beyonce eve had a hit movie. I supported it, because it’s hard for a sista(not in a Tyer Perry movie or Bond movie) to do well.
Beyonce, stay up there as long as you can. Stay strong, ignore the haters.
You are beautiful Beyonce.
Beauty,talent,class,brains,dignity and rich.
All the Respect to you.
A Fan for life.
She’s in the league of Diana Ross, Beyonce will always be a Star.
“I was happy a sista who is lighter(tan)color brown skinned showed u on the scene and took the industry by storm. …”
taryn: You have a colour complex. You like bk bc she is a great singer & dancer, or bc she is a bit lighter and sings & dances?
I will pray for you.
Beyonce’ could come up with the cure for AIDS and people would say she should have done it ten years ago. Regardless of what she does, people will always look/find something negative to say about her and I believe it’s because
1.) She is the best at what she does. Truly. When you’re that good, people want to find something wrong with you.
2.) She is a freakin robot. You never see her in tabloids, getting drunk on tabletops and/or cussing people out. The girl is a freakin machine and her PR person deserves an award. She has managed to keep her image clean despite marrying gangsta Jay Z by being private and always on in front of the camera. Unlike the Kardashians who are the prime example of being attention whores, people have no idea what goes on her personal life which makes them speculate and start rumors because they want to know. If she did what Alicia Keys did to Mashonda regarding Swizz Beats, the world would CRUCIFY this woman. Funny how Alicia still has the same amount of love and hardly anyone thinks less of her.
thats how the world its its a dog eat dog world of course they’re gonna bash on celebrities because thts how it is of course people not gon praise beyonce’ 24/7 thats jus how it is .
i told myself i wasnt going to comment but i read all the comments ndd..GET A LIFE..yall is some haters i cant believe how hard yall hate on beyonce…what she do to yall..but here are reasons yall hate she is gorgeous yall aint; she can sing yall cant; she skinny yall def aint; she make big bucks shall i say more… yall hate on bee cause yall cant be her…i wanna be nice on this but haters like yall make it impossible to be…and for all the haterz who say beyonce is copycat name one celeb who aint…alrighty then shut up cause every single one does…nd if you make blogs like this you mind as well be beyonces BIGGEST FAN… yup thats it yall love beyonce…beyonce is the best she will always be and if yall got a problem oh well..she will forever be beyonce giselle knowles..nd haterz will be haters buh-bye…
P.S-the person who made this grow up ndd stop hating im pretty sure green aint a good color on you ndd envy is a sin…god is gonna get you..lmao!=]
lol girl trust aint nobody envyin’ her . its called criticism everyone gets it . &everyone sins thats why we’re called humans so im sure he’s gonna get yu for something as well so um yu can send that smiley &lmao to yurself(:
[...] there are several reasons not to. Clutch Magazine listed fifteen. But they fell short. Here are [...]
Critic does not equal hate or jealously. Why is critic within the Black culture forbidden? White people are able to analyze Brittany’s music and personal for poor musical and artists quality that it is. Why is it so controversial to apply the same intelligent perspective to Beyonce?
Critic does not equal hate or jealously. Why is critic within the Black culture forbidden? White people are able to analyze Brittany’s music and stage persona for poor musical and artistic quality. Why is it so controversial to apply the same intelligent perspective to Beyonce?
Simone,
Some are not articulate enough to tell us what’s so good about Beyonce besides the superficials things so they go to “you are hating”. People list good reasons why they don’t like her yet other say it’s hating. Goes to show they see what we are saying.
I’m not a fan.
She doesn’t give me that feeling like wow.
THere is nothing to hate on her. Stupid ass licking fans, there is a difference between critism and jealously. Yall are so ignorant u dont know the difference. You think, oh, shes Beyonce, she cant do nothing wrong.
People see beauty and think a person has talent.
Real talent is when u can create and be original, which B definitely doesn’t have.
Everybody can sing and dance, it comes from the heart. But it doesn’t seem she sings and dances from the heart. She dances like a hoochie, shaking her ass.
With her singing expectually with Halo, you see it in her face that she’s trying so hard to sound enchanting and its not working out for her.
Her songs have wrong messages.
Also, she wants to be everywhere. People are already sick of her.
But its whatever, you people will never view this on an intelligent level. I view things in a perfectionist/ critical way.
lol my mom is sickk of seeing her everywhere &im the same way she’s okay but she’s an entertainer not an artist like alicia keys who actual makes her own music .
There is no need to be insulting. Personally this block on why people hate Beyonce is a critic and I have nothing against it. The people who are commenting should be very careful. Beyonce is most definately not perfect. There is no way she will ever be. Because she is human. but we cannot sit on our white horse and behave as if we are perfect. YOU SEE IT IN HER FACE…….what do you see? Lets be very careful.
um for all the beyonce haters yall need t stop what she eva did to u she is just antuha celebrity trynna live her life & if you think for one minute she isnt like you not one bit listen to her songs all of them they show some sighn of rebellion or anger or poverity or something why dont you like her you dnt even know her & she doesnt know you so please stop & if you have any concerns or questions my aim is
dyonna1228
or my myspace or facebook
dyonna1228@aol.com
p.s i love beyonce & will kill for her so STOP !
why would yu wanna kill for someone who doesnt even know yu let alone think of yu ????
@dyonna
You might be a little unstable with that statement. That was taking it wayyyyy to far!
Why would I listen to you? You can’t even type! If I don’t like her songs, videos and just plain old think that she is overrated well then thats that. You are just obsessed and need to get a grip. I am in no way jealous of her and think that I can relate to her. So what if she can express emotions in her songs we already know that she is human and some musicians can serve as actors vocally too. If you didn’t get what Beyonce was trying to incorporate in her album is that some people assume different personalities and that you might have been listening to the wrong person the entire time. If you like her fine but other people don’t so get over yourself. I think she would kill to stay way from you!
and youre mad because youre not as talented or not even half as talented as she is HATERS YALL GON HATE BUT DNT PUT IT ON THE NET LOOSAS
Beyonce is self-centered and she thinks the world revolves around her. She is talented but not original. She steals music and even choreography. These stans seriously need to see who “sweet” B really is? Her music has turned in to nothing but perversion and whether you want to believe it or not, she is in the Illuminati.
You can say that again! :)
im not jealous of B im honestly glad &happy not to be her because she is apart of that illuminati crap her &her evil husband so they can go about their happy evil lives wether yu wanna beileve it or not its true(: she’s most def. a hypocrite / she said always stay humble awhile bckk wen she was with destiny’s child but now look .
Sigh. Not that illuminati sh*t again. Your proof is what?
Bk has success b4 she met Carter, so why do u say her success is due to the masons/ illuminati ?