18

2010 Census: Another Abuse of the Government?

Monday Mar 22, 2010 – by

Over $400 billion lies in the balance. Over $130 million in advertising dollars was spent to get people to participate. An eager Congress awaits the results of the 2010 Census so they could better serve our country, tend to the shifting demographics and allocate funding fairly across the downtrodden and underfunded among us.

An accurate census count determines how many lawmakers each state will have in the House of Representatives. But what does that mean to a nation who has seen its politicians let them down through partisan rancor, inert policy-making and ulterior agendas?

Considering the political theater in Washington these days, it would be a miracle if Congress could quickly decide what pizza to order for lunch, much less the adept allocation of billions of dollars. The skepticism that many show toward the Census is understandable and in many ways, justified. But is apathy toward this decade’s first census the appropriate response?

This is the 23rd head count in U.S. history and for many areas, the litmus test for how explosive Hispanic growth has been over the past ten years. In Maryland, for example, preliminary Census reports indicate at least a 60 percent growth. Congresswoman Donna Edwards (D-Md.) has spearheaded a full-court press for getting the full participation of Hispanics.

There is nothing in the Census form that asks about citizenship status, said the U.S. Department of Commerce Regional Director Fernando Armstrong. So illegal immigrants have nothing to worry about.

Red flag.

If that’s the case, then is the government willing to shell out tax dollars to those who may not be U.S. citizens? Or are they ready to use this information to perform a simple audit to find out how many Hispanics are here illegally versus those registered? Once that information is handy, what will the government do with it?

Only American citizens have the constitutional authority to determine tax allotments and the number of representatives in the House. So why are U.S. Census takers courting the participation of people who they know have no legal standing to participate? Such dubious outreach claims ring loud in certain circles. Many celebrities, including newest Oscar winner Monique, has implored everybody to go out and complete their Census.

Under federal law, individuals can be fined for not completing census questionnaires. But constitutionally speaking, only the state of the resident and number of people living in your house is required. Nothing about your name, race/ethnicity, sex, age, date of birth, relationship or housing tenure is necessary for tax allocation or political voice.

The fact nothing in the advertisements indicates such is another flag. Color this one maroon.

We, the U.S. citizens, have been bound to a contract with the government since birth. This is an unofficial-official contract that states that we must pay taxes, be a civic asset and know the law. In return, the government will provide us with services (protection, education, medical care), allow us the rights of the land and to a fair trial (habeas corpus).

But everyday there are breaches of this contract in action. Some examples:

  • We are required to pay taxes, yet there is nothing in government-funded schools that teaches us how to fill out a  W-2  and W-4 tax form. Without the aid of H&R Block and Turbo Tax, many of us would be clueless.
  • We’re asked to support the government (“Ask not what your country can do for you, ask what you can do for your country.”) but the government can illegally tap your phone and keep us in the dark about the military acts that tax dollars fund.
  • Ignorance of the law is no defense, but there is little more than a civics class in high school to enlighten us into the crux of the law and the precedences set. Unless you’re a law aficionado, you will remain ignorant of the law.
  • Police officers, the protectors and servers, are funded by the people who routinely find themselves victims of dubious traffic stops and bullets from trigger-happy gentlemen.

The Census, which recently came under the watchful eye of the government, has entered into this contract. Contracts have a way of benefiting the contractor the most, and in the case of government agencies, it’s not any different. The only way to void the contract is to leave the country, which may not be the feasible move. By becoming aware of the contractual imbalances, we begin asserting our rights as citizens.

Instead of using this Census as only a call for privacy/power abuse, we’d be better served to use this as the latest leverage to hold the government contractors to their end of the bargain.

18 Comments – Add Yours

  1. avatar Alexandra says:

    I’m still pondering on whether I should fill the census out. My dad and mom have no intentions on filling it out. And my brother and his girlfriend aren’t interested either.

    All I took was one look at the census and it kinda made my stomach turn. They’re so nosy lol. Some Americans preach racial progression, but these racial statistics will not help that.
    I’m still contemplating on whether I should fill it out….

  2. avatar Clnmike says:

    Not filling out the census is like not voting you are taking your self out of the debate and not being counted when decisions are being made that WILL effect you and the country. It also negates your right to complain about goverment’s responsibility to it’s people.

  3. avatar caramelgirl says:

    oh, Blah, blah blah blah blah. US Census this and US census that, Im so damn tired of the government and brainwashed celebrities trying to push this thing down my throat. They say take it and be counted, I say that is bullshit. The government does not care, it will not try to work for your favor or benefit without it getting something out of it as well. You must be extremely weary of the government and whatever they do, especially when they claim they want to “help”. Anyone who knows US history knows all about the damn “help” they’ve given out to cultures who werent the majority(whites) from establishment, independence and til this day. It seems to me like everytime they try to “help”, people get hurt in the process. I say if they really want to help they dont need a damn census to do it, just ride by the hoods and see how we’re doing, not read some paper.

  4. avatar caj says:

    i agree with Clnmike. I understand your anger towards the government and their ineptness, but despite that fact, the physical people in government, and their competence or incompetence, are temporary to the overall effect that the census has on the long-term health and state of our country. If the US does not have accurate data on the demographics, etc. of the nation, how can it properly serve those who live within it. Everyone in government could be replaced with the most competent, good-willed, and effective people, but with no accurate data to help them determine the needs of each region of the country, they will be as effective as the current Congress is. Just like a democracy, the overall structure and intention of it is inherently good, those who run it make it flawed; but it is still necessary to keep things moving along and to help most accurately represent the people who live here. Being angry at the government for not doing what you think they should is perfectly healthy, use the democratic system and vote your official out. Not participating in the census will not only take yourself out of the conversation, it will also decrease your chances of being heard. The more people with your same sentiments who do not compete the census in your area, town, city, etc., the less representation you have, and the greater chance that those areas who did complete it will be able to put people in office that will go after THEIR needs, which might not be your own.

  5. avatar Eki Wilson says:

    The soliloquies on “the government is up to no good, damn them” get a little draining. Just fill out the form. Really. Geez. If you’re not a “negro” there is still a box to check. Though there is plenty of corruption and ill will directed towards our communities and demographic, everyone is not out to get us. We don’t have to prostest everything. I’m not here for back and forth debating either. I’m just saying…

  6. avatar Sia says:

    If you are one of the ones refusing to fill out the census, don’t complain when they shut our schools, hospitals, and other services down. But I can bet that when that day comes you will just be out there pointing the blame at “the government” when you really should be blaming yourself! This whole “my voice doesn’t coun’t anyways” BS is what is destroying our communities.

  7. avatar kia, jd says:

    I always wonder about people who go on about “the government”. To which part of government are you actually referring? The executive (Obama)? The legislature (Congress)? The numerous agencies established to carry out legislation (DOT, HHS)? Do you know or are you just referring to what the gubmint did or didn’t do for you today? I find that the average person doesn’t really understand how government works or how things like the Census can impact your life.
    Our education system is partly to blame. Civics and government are afterthoughts in most districts. Though we’re encouraged to participate in government, a lot of it is too cumbersome for the average person to worry about – especially when there are bills and things due.

    If you really think the Census is something BAD or NEGATIVE or DETRIMENTAL to you and your community, show me some proof. Otherwise, just fill it out. Folks spend more time commenting on blogs, I suspect.

  8. avatar Drew-Shane says:

    everyone is pushing the Census. makes me think it’s a hidden agenda also

    • avatar kia, jd says:

      I’m interested in hearing more about this because I’m having trouble accepting the blanket idea that if “everyone” is pushing it than there must be something shady going on. The Census is not new, nor is it just now being “pushed”. Every 10 years it’s the same thing. But seriously, there has got to be more to it than “everyone is pushing the Census. makes me think it’s a hidden agenda also.”

  9. avatar Dot says:

    What I understand about Americans (in general) is why you fear the government…I truly don’t understand that!

    No other country in the developed world is as afraid of its government than the United States. You pay taxes so you can demand a service! Your money paid for those censuses so why wouldn’t you fill it out?

    In France, England, Spain and even Canada, people take it to the streets if they feel that their government isn’t responding to their needs. Granted, the electoral system is different, but people don’t fear their government. They get angry!

    When you pay taxes and fill out your census, you expect something in return! Taxes isn’t free money; its money with conditionality!

  10. avatar Ben says:

    Nobody has commented on the elephant in this article:

    “Under federal law, individuals can be fined for not completing census questionnaires. But constitutionally speaking, only the state of the resident and number of people living in your house is required. Nothing about your name, race/ethnicity, sex, age, date of birth, relationship or housing tenure is necessary for tax allocation or political voice.

    The fact nothing in the advertisements indicates such is another flag?”

    Know your rights and realize that when the government ask for anything above what is constitutionally protected, you SHOULD ASK QUESTIONS. We should definitely hold the government accountable to their end of the contract (which the author of this piece did a good job of pointing out). Barack Obama extended Bush and Dick Cheney heinous’ Patriot Act, and I don’t recall a single soul being in outrage about that (OK, I’m exaggerating, but really, few people even acknowledged it).

    Hold your government accountable. This Census is another tool to do that.

    Great piece. I’ll be forwarding along.

  11. avatar steven says:

    black people especially need to fill out the census if not for any other reason than to provide an accurate marker of their lives for their ancestors. my family knows the birth date, hometown, number of siblings, and children of my maternal great grandparents because they filled out the census in 1930.

    i’m all for skepticism, but i think this time it might be misplaced.

    I also wonder why anyone would complain about the failures of congress and then advocate not to have more seats in the legislature. the majority of the problems related to congress come from the fact that it is a small, tight knit, secretive boys club with access to unlimited funds from lobbyists that have little accountability to the people they serve. More elected officials in congress may lead to more accountability and therefore better policies and service.

  12. avatar Clnmike says:

    There are also government funding grants and servicesthat are population based as well. There are small communities that get more then their share of funding because they count there prison population regardless if the prisoners come from the community or not. Thats funding that can go to the communities that produce them and prevent the cycle from continuing.

  13. avatar lazonia says:

    My understanding, if you refused to fill out and return the census. you will be fine.-dictatorsip. If you take too long to respond, they call you and asked have you received the survey. Then they give you the opportunity to take it over the phone. After taking the survey, a few days later you have another survey in you mail. What is becoming of this country. Where is the democracy? How those dumb ass question will help us? I have no idea.

  14. avatar Truth1 says:

    THERE IS NO SUCH THING AS GOV. FUNDS!!!!!!! THIS IS YOUR FREAKING TAX $’S …WAKE THE @#$% UP PPL!!! THEY SPENT OVER 120 MILLION ADVERTISING THIS BULLSHyT CENSUS…NOW THEY WANT TO FORCE YOU TO COMPLY?… FUQ THAT…..READ YOUR CONSTITUTION U SHEEP!!!! BTW… FEDERAL INCOME TAX IS ILLEGAL…

  15. avatar Ashley says:

    All people do on here is complain! Its the Census! If you can take the time to post comments to this blog you can take 5 minutes to fill it out and drop it in the mail. All they want to do is properly distribute resources. Don’t be mad when your community goes to hell later. Then it will be an article about how the government won’t help us.

  16. [...] so many of us reluctant to participate? The comments to a recent article on Clutch Magazine reveals some of the more common attitudes about the Census. Zettler Clay, the author of the article, notes: There is nothing in the Census [...]

  17. avatar twocents says:

    A lot of the comments I describe as ” people trying to be so cool that it becomes uncool”. Yes the government is not 100% on point; When black people are trying to advocate for what the black community needs in funding, how can they do this to the fullest if you aren’t contributing your numbers. The Census is only every 10 years, so please help your community for the next 9 years by sending in the form. Unfortunately they have resorted to guerilla tactic reminders so that people actually turn them.

Leave a Comment

  • We moderate comments and prohibit personal attacks, threats, spam, lewd images, or the promotion of your personal website.
  • Please keep comments related to topic.
  • Follow us on Facebook and Twitter.

You are commenting as a Guest. Optional: Login below.

Daily Blog - News.Gossip.Info