I recently had the chance to sit down and watch Spike Lee’s 1986 film, She’s Gotta Have It. The main character, Nola Darling, is in a state of confusion about which man she wants to be with. One of the men, Jamie, is the average African American male who works hard and treats women well. Next, there’s Greer, the stuck up, self centered, controlling man and Lastly, Mars (played by Spike Lee) who never grows up, and can’t keep a job because all he wants to do is fool around and buy sneakers. There was also a lesbian named Opal, but Nola wasn’t having that. That’s another article anyway.
Throughout the movie Jamie, Greer and Mars reflect on the time they spent with Nola, and all their sexual encounters. Nola was with all three men at the same time on and off. What man would put up with that? Towards the end of the movie Nola admitted that she saw all three men as one, each man offering something that she needed. Jamie had stability, Greer had confidence and money and Mars simply made her laugh. Sounds like all the main qualities most women look for in a man. Who could blame her? But at the same time she was being unfair to all three men, and they were just as foolish for putting up with it.
As I sat and watched this unique film, I thought about how accurate this depiction was back then and still is today. How many women do this today? I’m pretty sure the percentage is very high among women of all races, just as the percentage of men with multiple women is high. I guess my question is why did she have to have it? As the movie progressed, she began to realize she didn’t really have to have it. I could tell when Jamie’s character was first introduced in the movie that he was the most complete person for Nola, but as usual people can’t always see what’s good for them. He respected her, didn’t talk down to her, and was responsible, unlike Mars and Greer. But Nola pushed Jamie away with her constant pursuit of the other two men. He began to see another woman, and told Nola to choose or one day she was going to look around and he would be gone. It wasn’t only Jamie who demanded her to make her mind up. Greer and Mars asked Nola to make a decision also. Nola dropped Greer and Mars and realized that Jamie really did love her and she really loved him. He gave her a second chance but still ended up alone in the end. In the last scene of the movie Nola asked herself, who can love me better than me?
“Who can love me better then me?”
How many women or men today do we see juggling multiple people and can’t recognize the right person for them, even when their staring them in the face? I don’t know the answer, but what I do know is that the people involved in a love triangle have to want to stop and change themselves or no one will be happy. Ultimately comes down to having standards and values and not being selfish. Also, those who are being used shouldn’t allow this behavior. How can something like this be solved?
Another point from the movie that I want to speak on is that whole idea of Jamie, Greer, and Mars being as one person to Nola. These three men each had parts to them that was attractive to Nola, and satisfied all of her needs. That’s why in the movie Nola could never make her mind up about who she wanted to be with. There were parts of each man that she needed, and couldn’t let go.
One could argue that this is a sensible reason for her behavior but at the same time not. Many women and men deal with this same thing every day. People might find that one person of the opposite sex that they are really attracted to, but there are also other people in the equation. Ladies, their might be a guy that you like and want to be with, but there’s another guy over here who satisfies a need.
What I’m trying to get at is this idea of needing multiple people to fulfill your needs can ultimately lead to someone getting hurt, and it’s not fair to all who are involved. People end up being used all the while thinking they were the one for you. So my other question is why can’t people just find one person who can satisfy all of their needs. Do we really have to go through this long, confusing ordeal and drag other people along? Can people just take the time to get to know one person? I know no one is perfect and may not be everything that you need, but there has to be someone who comes close, don’t you think? But we know people are going to do what they want to do. Nola and Mars.
” target=”_blank”>http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cjFem8_90sc
I THINK THERE ARE CERTIAN TIMES IN LIFE WHEN ITS necessary to jugle…as long as you explian it! its too late after you are married. I liked this movie, it was alright.
We are socialized to search for the perfect man. So when we don’t find him we invent him, even if it takes more than one man to do it.
p.s. MEN do this with little to no guilt!
wish u had a picture of what she looks like today.
nice read.
First I must say that this is my favorite movie of all time!!!
Let me count the ways…
1. The film is pure art – shot in black & white with only one scene in color (Nola’s Birthday). It was thoughtful in approach and will always be timeless and classic, visually and in content.
2. The dancer’s at Nola’s Birthday were amazing!! What a perfect birthday gift (for us hopeless romantics).
3. The film score is magnificent – So much so that Jose James covered the tune from Nola’s Birthday on his last album – the song is FIRE!!
4.The film’s content was so on point and reminded me so much of myself in my 20′s – It boiled down to Nola’s unreadiness to commit. Its wasn’t really about having multiple guys to fulfill multiple needs. It was more-so about figuring out what she really wanted and what will ultimately make her happy. As Nola discovered, you can’t be right for anyone else until you are whole and secure in yourself – that’s when the relationship best suited for you quickly rises above the pack, and is easily identifiable. Case in point, the love of my life is someone I’ve known since I was 15 years old. It took me over 15 years to realize he’s absolutely perfect for me, in every, single way. Had we dated in my teens or my 20′s would we have lasted? I can’t say confidently that we would have as we were both on individual paths of self-discovery. It takes two whole people to enter, and sustain a quality relationship. It also takes realness, honesty and willingness to develop and truly assess what works and doesn’t work in your life to pinpoint what is needed to live the life you’ve envisioned. Self-discovery is both scary and awakening… but completely cleansing to mind, body and soul.
I will always love this movie for its depth and realness in how folks really get down when trying to figure it all out.
P.S. Greer lives in Philly – I saw him as I was pulling out of my driveway one day…. His real-life personality is very much like his character from the film!! Hilarious!!
I understand the question being posed, but using “She’s Gotta Have It” as source material is so problematic. There are plenty of less controversial examples of fictional female characters juggling multiple men. Samantha Jones from SATC, anyone?
Nola wasn’t dating all three men at once because they each had something she needed. She was screwing them all because each had something she liked and wanted. There’s a difference. Yeah, Jamie was cool . . . until he raped Nola. Then, if memory serves me correctly, after the assault, Nola called up Jamie to apologize and reunite. WOW!
Given Spike’s history with his portrayals of women, you can’t help but be suspicious of Nola. Was she designed to be an empowered, sex positive female, or a manifestation of a sexually available male fantasy who equates casual sex with being liberated. I’m inclined to believe it’s the latter if for no other reason than the fact that Nola is punished for her sex positive lifestyle through sexual assault. And the rape scene was the climax of the film. Oh, the irony. Remember, Nola didn’t have her epiphany about being monogamous and didn’t decide to get rid of the other boyfriends until after she was assaulted by Jamie. Only after Jamie forcefully bends her over and gives her “what she wants” (cause, remember, she’s gotta have it) does she consider the “error of her ways”.
I must say in MY opinion (as not to offend)
The focus on the what is really going on in this movie has not been addressed once
I don’t think this movie is at all about Nola Darlings quest to find the right man by quenching different desires and parts of her personality and juggling relationships.
Yes she tries on these different characters who do feed certain needs but only commits when to put it bluntly, when given an ultimatum. She did have genuine feelings for Jamie, but she did not want to commit. And ultimately, doesn’t.
The score of the movie tells the story…
“There she goes on her merry way
though she’s only queen for a day”
It’s much like Van Hunt’s Hot Stage Lights
It’s hard to be everything to one person when the focus is solely on you. It’s much easier to be viewed and treated as their Queen… even for a day at a time. Relationships are lots of pressure. What if you let them down? What if you let yourself down? What if you fall short of their expectations? Yeah, those may seem like questions one should never ask themselves when they are okay with who they are but this movie is about GROWTH.
No one wants to be viewed as common or ordinary and if you don’t allow anyone the opportunity or time to view you as such, you don’t run the risk.
And on the other side of that same coin, being non committal and juggling people allows you the ability to show them only what you want them to see of you. You can be that impressionable student of life as she was with Greer. You can be that experienced-all-together idealistic woman, as she was to Mars. You can be able to peek at your mature committed feminine side, as she did with Jamie. But make it clear, she was not committed to any one of those ideals of herself.
This movie is not about men or juggling them… or finding the right one… or any of that. It’s an introspective view of different parts of one woman. The men were merely catalysts.
The movie is about growth and self knowledge and one woman’s journey at achieving that.
Its cool that you found a way to reference a Van Hunt song.
Great article.
I never looked at the character as fufilling her needs though by dating the three men as opposed to her not knowing what she wanted so as a result not placing herself in a position of making a choice which was forced upon her in the end.
The only sin with doing this to me is not being honest with your self and the people involved.
I LOVE everything Spike Lee does, his movies speak volumes about our existence so poetically, they are truly beautiful and She’s Gotta Have It is like my life’s story right now….. nice piece
I saw this movie for the first time two weeks ago and absolutely fell in love!! I’ve been obsessed with it ever since (i.e. waiting up until the middle of the night last friday to watch it again), so thanks for featuring it.
As far as Nola is concerned, I love her character because she is completely honest about the whole thing from the very start of the film. Not once does she lie about anything, even going as far as having all of the men over for a family-style Thanksgiving dinner. Personally I am a diehard “one man” woman, but I think its cool that she was able to explore different options and stay true to herself while being honest with everyone involved. In the end she realized even Jamie wasn’t for her, and that maybe its okay to just love sex and multiple men. Maybe some people just aren’t made for commitment…or at least not the ones that cause you to compromise yourself and beliefs. ( like her being with Jamie…the “nice guy” who RAPED her)
I love She’s Gotta Have It. It’s simply shot, but the story line is complex. I loved that no one could ever figure Nola out. She was just living life.
thanks for the feedback everybody
I think Isolde has it right. Nola gets punished for ‘being sexual.’ bell hooks writes an amazing essay about this movie.
Question: Don’t we all in our dating life at one time or another just wanted to ‘date around’ and not settle down yet?