On Thanksgiving 2009, I hit a man with my Totes bubble umbrella. He was an older gentleman but spry, White, rude, and buzzed off of Beaujolais or some other Turkey chaser. His graying wife on his arm, this man mowed me into oncoming traffic at the corner of Central Park West and 59th street in New York City and kept stepping. I collected myself and marched after him. “Sir. Sir. Excuse me, sir. You just ran me into the street.” His back to me, he mumbled, “Well, sorry” and waved a dismissive hand. I wasn’t having it, so I picked up the pace, called for his attention and whacked him on the arm with my umbrella. A bystander, a middle-aged White male who had witnessed both acts of violence, caught my eye and exclaimed, “You shouldn’t have done that,” and then fended off the retaliation-seized senior and his wife.
I said, “He shouldn’t have run me into the street.” My good Samaritan, and my sister with whom I had just shared a peaceful vegan Thanksgiving meal at a nearby restaurant, were concerned for my safety and chided me for putting myself in harm’s way.
In May of 2010, I yelled at an elderly woman food cart vendor. My mother, who had lost her mother the day before, was parking her rental car in midtown, blocks away from Western Union. As she was backing into the spot, this vendor beckoned her to roll down her window and then asked her how long she intended to be parked there. The hour my mother overestimated was not to the vendor’s liking, as she intended to use the spot to move her cart from the sidewalk onto the street come closing time—so she instructed us to park elsewhere, and my mom nodded acquiescently despite having circled for some time to find the spot in question.
This is where I came in. No one, not even an elderly food cart vendor, was going to stop my mom from parking in a legal public parking spot anytime — especially not the day after she lost her mother, and especially not as she made her way to wire money to her native Nigeria to tend to funeral costs and her mentally ill brother in advance of her arrival. Suffice it to say, this old woman got hers and much, much more. Bystanders, many of whom were certainly her clientele, gave me dirty looks. My mom looked embarrassed but remained quiet. Later, as we drove back uptown, I quipped that my outburst would be perfect for a “Dateline” hidden camera segment on mean people or, more to the point, people who yell at elderly working class immigrants on city streets.
In both cases, I was right. It’s not OK to run anyone into the street, although one damning feature of White privilege is a predilection for running people of color off sidewalks. It’s not OK to stop anyone from parking in a legal public parking spot, but I understand I looked bad expressing my disdain for both transgressions.
These are occasional flashes of anger, directed at those insensitive enough to do me or my loved ones wrong and draw my ire. A few years ago I made a decision to let it all out, to not swallow the fire but to let it burn others. There is something really liberating about expressing anger. There are so many feelings a generally composed, polite, private school-educated, Christian, self-help obsessed, golden-rule charged, person like me suppresses. I don’t do jealousy, having recognized it as a product of my own insecurities. Low self-esteem: I have tried to chuck along with the narcissism that powers it. Loneliness, I don’t wallow in. I either initiate new social situations and meet new people, or spend quality time with old friends and family. With all of this high-minded restraint, I felt like I’d edited myself into a ball of blah, lost all dynamic range—no lows, no highs. So I recovered them—until I got hit with the back draft.
The blow back of being Black, woman, and angry, is that the anger serves no purpose other than reaffirming the stereotype that Black women are angry. I don’t want to be Kita or Monique from “The T.O. Show.” I don’t want to be Rochelle from “Everybody Hates Chris.” I just want to be a woman with some moments of frailty. I don’t have the stamina to always stay above the fray and I work out six days a week. I just want to be myself.
I decided against anger as a tween. I was reading Ecclesiastes for church school, and there was something in there about anger being futile. In fact, I think Ecclesiastes charged all things as futile, but anger’s indictment stuck with me. I’d witnessed anger eat folks up and stress them out. I wanted to be happy, still do, and I see anger as being an impediment to that Mary J. Bligian goal, not because it will eat me up inside—I feel light as a feather after I regulate those in need of regulation—but because it will reduce me to a stale type.
Negresses ain’t perfect, and this one is always trying to be better—but I can’t win for occasional losing it, and that kind of pisses me off. I understand anger is unproductive, but its cathartic. And every now and then there are things I need to expel, to get off my chest, to get out of my heart, so I can breathe. But I’m retiring that part of me. I’m going to hold onto the umbrella because it does a great job of protecting my flat-ironed hair—but I’ll no longer be using it as an instrument of harm. I’ll try not to weaponize my words either. I don’t see it working for me. I’ve picked up running so I can pound it all out on pavement—decimating my gimpy knees, and disproving both the “Angry Black Woman” and “Black Women Don’t Run” stereotypes with singular stony intent.
I like this piece alot :) This topic has been on my mind lately. I do like that you have found alternate (and much more healthier) ways of expressing socially unacceptable emotions. Esp the kind that reinforces negative stereotypes. I think that if it works for you it’s great! It’s a shame that as human beings we don’t get the privilege to be completely autonomous as there is always some big stereotype shadow glooming over us and serving to police our actions.
I recently decided to stop blowing up and be more sarcastic. ALthough this may not be the best remedy, it works for me . I figured I’d sharpen my tongue wile challenging some mofos
:)
I understand your concern about ‘proving’ a stereotype. A lot of people dont like being put in a box. But I hope you are not too focused on not ‘not being a stereotype’ that you live your life trying to appease people. Everyone gets angry; it’s human nature. Some people just dont know how to control it. Are black women not allowed to get angry?
For black women, a sterotype is already there & thats why I said, I hope you’re not too focused on it. We can all assume what ‘type’ of angry black women people think of, but people are gonna stereotype regardless.
People care what other people think of them, to an extent? I guess being angry is one for some. Ehhh, I used to care….
I’ve never gotten into loud arguments with people in the streets where public attention was brought to it. But I was snappy in HS. Like secretaddy said, I was always sarcastic with a slick mouth. It really isn’t a good choice sometimes (fights), but I prefer it over screaming matches. Sarcasm hits the right spot.
I agree with you. Anger can become consuming, and I hate when someone’s lack of manners consumes my emotions. I’m working on live and let live, and recognizing that some folks are jerks, or that even when I’m right, I don’t have to absolutely go to the mat with it. I don’t want to blow up, stroke out, then have my headstone read, “But She Was Right.” No bueno.
At the same time, I also agree with Alexandra. Don’t take it upon yourself to be the representation for all Negresses everywhere. The people who want to believe that angry women who don’t take care of their bodies is the norm are going to believe that, not matter how much you grin, bear it, and run. That being said, expressing anger does not have to result in a nuclear blowout. Sometimes, taking that extra pause is all you need to be able to express your feelings in a way that is clear, without being harmful.
But kudos to you!
@secretaddy & @alexandra Thanks for your comments. I don’t do sarcasm well or wit for that matter or else I would take your suggestions. ; ) I wish I could shed this anxiety about stereotypes but they keeping on cropping up and as you noted policing me. Increasingly, I find myself willing to make some concessions about my behavior. I won’t compromise my character but I will modify my behavior if I find it unproductive as I negotiate my way through the world. This is not ideal but I think it might be the reality for those of us who don’t top the totem pole.
@Afrodyte Thanks for your comment. I agree with you that anger, like fire, consumes. In the instances above I felt like a dragon. I scorched others but remained burn free. If I am to fully abandon anger, I’m going to have to figure out a way to not let it manifest in the first place. I’m sure that I can but I don’t know that I really want to. I wonder what contours of my personality, what elements of the range of human expression I will have to concede.
How about changing your perspective a bit (and this is in reference to white men not moving out of your way).
What if you refuse to move out of their way?
Try walking in a straight line, and see who gives you the right away.
I’ve tried it, and am no longer passively bumped into. Instead, I will walk up to someone’s nose if need be, knock shoulders with them, and send the message that you (old white man) do not control the sidewalks.
Yes, this may seem like a childish game. And in a sense, it is. Think of another way to approach the road. It can make walking more fun and less of a battlefield.
Instead of abandoning anger (which is impossible), try sitting with it. When you feel the emotion arise, do as @Sloane suggests and verbally recognize how angry you are. Sometimes just saying “I am angry” is enough to clear your mind so that you may effectively communicate to others exactly why you are experiencing the emotion.
Thank you for the read. This really speaks to me.
“I wish I could shed this anxiety about stereotypes but they keeping on cropping up and as you noted policing me. Increasingly, I find myself willing to make some concessions about my behavior. I won’t compromise my character but I will modify my behavior if I find it unproductive as I negotiate my way through the world.”
-I agree. I used to allow stereotypes to affect me & who I was. Sometimes I found myself worried, if I was being boxed into a ‘black female stereotype’. I even ‘acted’ different.
When I first started working at my schools newspaper one of the staff members asked me the most dumbest, ignorant questions I’ve ever heard. I couldnt even respond, but just laugh and shake my head. I was like: “Is this how some people really think”? This was from someone who i thought was cool. And the ignorant questions/jokes kept coming up. I know. It’s really annoying.
No more annoying when in some cases if you dont fit their box, they become angry and stress that you are a stereotype. Trying to tell you, who you are.
But all this did was make me distant and somewhat anti-social. Then I thought oh well, people already have their stereotypes in their head. They are going to stereotype you whether you like it or not. There’s no time for that. Not in my life. Either you like me or you dont.
But I do agree, that while you shouldn’t change who you are to appease others, I think its respectful to control your anger & respect yourself.
“This is not ideal but I think it might be the reality for those of us who don’t top the totem pole.”
Not again. Whose totem pole?
Yes, yes, yes!!! Love this article. You are so right.
i love this article. for a long time, when i was younger i used to hold all of my anger in and used to be a doormat who was depressed ( i heard from a therapist that anger directed inwards is depression). i literally used to think that people treating me in a disrespectful manner was ALWAYS my fault. once i learned that sometimes people are just assholes, and that sometimes other people’s initial behavior towards you is out of your control, i’ve gotten better at managing my emotion. anger is a part of being a human, and is sometimes a healthy emotion to express. it can also be affective in letting people know they’ve crossed a line and that you don’t take any sh*t. i have no problem in saying that i’m angry and letting people know that they’ve angered me. i also believe in letting people know they’ve said or done something ridiculous through sarcasm and wit, though that’s not my forte. being a smartass can be fun.
r u on twitter, we shld follow each other
@secretaddy is my screen name
@secretaddy- no i’m not on twitter, but i’ll look your’s up. you ALWAYS have some insightful and well thought out commentary.
emotions*
Oh my gosh I had a mouthful of cuss words ready for the man who cut me off in traffic this morning. I was so angry I was shaking. The only thing that stopped me from letting him have it verbally was that he swerved a maneuvered between a tight crack of bumper to bumper cars (he was driving a tiny Toyota Yarus) and was gone before I could catch up with him.
So what if people see me as an “angry Black Woman”. Heck, I’m Black and I’m a woman and I get angry. Let the others deal with it while I freely express my feelings. It’s not like I go around spitting on people or picking fights, but if someone does something that puts me in a state of anger, do I not have the right like any other woman on the planet to express it. It’s unhealthy to hold on to such a volatile emotion. Honestly, cussing out the man in the Toyota this morning would have been out of character for me, but that is just how angry he made me.
I enjoyed this article. I do not necessarily go off, but I have made impressions on my peers that I have low tolerance for “foolishness” or that I can be serious. To me, this translates as a nice way of saying I seem “angry.” I am actually a very sensitive person, and I hate feeling angry. It is such a hard emotion for me to understand; to the point where I wish the feeling didn’t exist. I think as a young woman, it is hard to know how to deal with that emotion. When you feel sadness or grief or depression, people are usually willing to help out and support you. Whenever I feel anger, or others around me, I feel the reaction has been to deal with that on your own. People tell you to go cool off. When you’re crying and sad, people give you a hug. Even is someone is “angry” they are still a human being, and other human emotions are hidden underneath it. We’re not made of teflon, even though we may seem to be riding high and strong by “going off.” One line stuck out to me:
“The blow back of being Black, woman, and angry, is that the anger serves no purpose other than reaffirming the stereotype that Black women are angry.”
Anger must serve an additional purpose than that. We are human beings first, and humans have this emotion for a reason! The stereotype is of black women who let anger consume their personalities and dispostions in life-not the mere fact that they can be angry. My mom, plenty of black women I know and myself don’t ever fit the stereotypical ABW, but we all feel anger and express it in different ways. I don’t want to feel like due to a stereotype, I have no right to experience a universal human emotion-especially for fear of someone watching me and labeling me. There is a purpose to the madness. We just have to figure out how it can be productive in our lives, or at least better maintained, so it doesn’t cause us to be silently bitter women (in my case) or umbrella weilding regulators. Or like the infamous Tasha Mack on “The Game.” It’s the way we handle anger that is stereotyped-not feeling the anger itself. This is something that resonates with me, because for years it has been hard for me to forgive myself for ever feeling angry at all. I’m still grappling with that emotion. And I don’t want myself or my sisters to have another reason to deny exploring this emotion within ourselves, just for fear of being the ABW.
This is so true Najat. I worry so often about expressing emotions and how I will be perceived that I don’t express anything. There is a constant internal audit of how every action or word will make me look to others. I know this isn’t just my problem though because it affects my relationships with the people who love me, including my husband. The emotional wall was built through years of the small hurts inflicted on a young girl/woman. And the adult woman is still living with the remnants. Anger is part of the journey and controlling me is one of the goals.
http://www.cnn.com/2010/LIVING/06/16/o.how.to.use.anger/index.html
this article talks about what I was trying to say.
@Kenyatta Thanks!
@Sloane @Najat @JustMe Thank you! “Sometimes other people’s initial behavior towards you is out of your control.” – @Sloane Indeed. ALL of the time. I checked out the article @Najat posted (Thank you for that!) and I was struck by this pull quote, “Anger is a sign that something needs to change.” True. But some shit we can’t change so maybe the most efficient thing to do is blow up and move on. Also like @JustMe yesterday morning, I think anger directed at strangers is different than anger directed at loved ones. I rarely subject my loved ones to rage and when I do, I feel HORRIBLE. But when it comes to strangers, I don’t really worry about it. That said, in the same way a kind word can brighten a strangers day a negative word could send one into despair. And @JustMe I’m so sad that this driver so perturbed you that you were shaking and that is the way you were forced to start your day. That’s a horrible feeling and one that I haven’t had in some time. As odd as it may sound, I’m serene when I’m angry. I don’t fly off the handle so much as make a decision to not let the anger bubble and rise in my own body to the point that I’m shaking and let someone else have it instead.
thanks jalylah for this piece. having been with you once when you’ve raised your voice, i totally dig it. of course, i want you to be healthy and happy with how you play it out. i try to keep myself on the audre lorde model, recognizing that anger is not only a natural response to an unjust world (i think lorde calls it “a grief of distortions”), but it’s productive use (by black women, especially!) might be one of the most viable ways to a better future. so i let myself pursue anger often. its not always easy to do that without doing harm to myself or others, but thank goodness we can also fuel a back-draft of forgiveness, peace, and love. until soon. <3
I won’t go as far to say that anger is a useless emotion. To the contrary. Every emotion has its purpose. That said, I think most of us devote too much time and attention, not to mention energy – both mental and physical – to it. We also lend ourselves to anger for things that neither deserve nor warrant it.
I think that we as humans, regardless of black women or not need to control the actions of our anger. It is okay to get angry, but what will you do when you are angry? How far will your anger take you…people have died for some of the dumbest things on the account of someone acting on anger. Learn to get angry and pick your battles, don’t let your anger control you.
Good points. I agree. Some people never let it go
I get angry, but its never prolonged. Anger shouldn’t be prolonged, thats way too much negativity & energy.
Honestly, I view the so called angry black women stereotype as false. I can’t speak for others but when I stand up for myself and say you are wrong and show dislike for something then automatically you are label angry when you are really not. I guess I’ am odd because my mother told me all my emotions matter and if I’ am angry I had the right to be it. I refust to sugarcoat my feelings to be deem in a certain light, nor does me expressing my anger means automatically I’ am going to act a fool and rip you a new one. There is a right way and wrong way to handle things, anger included. I think sometimes we need to stop apologizing for the way we feel and how we express it. Yes, we do need to pick our battles and need to learn when to not let our emotions come over us in some situations but to me all of our emotions matter and should be express from time to time, even anger. To me anger is a two way street, trying to hold it in, dismount it or whatever is just as bad as letting it rip 24/7. Everything in moderation including anger.
the law of ausar-
your nature is an unconquerable peace-
therefore nothing or no one in the world can be against you-
all experiences come to you to promote your reclamation of peace
that you may in turn acquire wisdom and power