I knew it would happen sooner or later. A single girl of a certain age working in a top retailer’s bridal registry department, it’s like asking for someone to pour salt in an open wound. But this woman, with a smile as big as the stone on her ring finger, was nothing but pleasant as she asked one question after the other about fine china and silverware.
“Now that you’ve answered all my questions,” she paused, her sunny expression shifting into one of sisterly concern. “I have one for you.”
I braced for it, the questions about the “special guy” in my life, a pitying look at my naked left ring finger. But her eyes drifted up to my hair – I was caught in that weird space any beginning natural girl learning how to love her hair knows all too well.
“Who does your hair?”
My thoughts raced, immediately calling to mind similar interactions with mean girls of high school. I explained I had just moved to town and hadn’t found a new stylist yet, but that I was transitioning to a natural do. I felt the growing disapproval in her gaze.
“Girl, I work in a corporate setting with” – she lowerd her voice, just in case the bone china was bugged to sniff out ethnic espionage – “white people. And sisters have to look 10 times more presentable to get ahead and run things. We’re not just representing ourselves, we’re representing the community.
“Now if you want to be natural, be natural,” though her expression and her sleek, relaxed bob showed she believed that was the least viable option. “Or if you want to relax it, you can do that too. I don’t know how to do my own hair, I’m in my hair stylist’s chair every Saturday morning. But you have to do something with that hair. You’re obviously a cute, intelligent girl. You just have to work on your appearance and catch you a man. I’ll email you some hairstylists’ numbers. We’re sisters. We have to look out for each other.”
There’s a lot to detangle in her W.E.B. DuBois-esque call to the Talented Tenth and hair politicking that was dumped in my lap that afternoon. But at the core of this exchange was what I’ll call, a sistah moment.
That’s right, a sistah moment. Similar to “the ‘n***a’ moment” in Aaron McGruder’s “Boondocks.” A sistah moment involves two or more African-Americans with no previous history thrown together with explosive results. However, unlike McGruder’s “n***a moment,” the sistah moment is way more complex than a shoot out over a bumped shoulder or a scuffed Nike in a crowded club. In fact, there are two types of sistah moments.
In the moment I experienced, Sistah #1, acting as a representative for the entire African-American community, sees a flaw in unsuspecting Sistah #2. This flaw is – consciously or unconsciously – bringing down the entire race. This flaw can be anything from hair to “bad” parenting. But in any case, Sistah #1 informs Sistah #2 of her offense. Before Sistah #2 can respond (“How dare you? You don’t know me!”), Sistah #1 whips out her “Get Out of Jail Free” card and whispers: “We’re sistahs. If I can’t tell you, who can?”
And that’s the question I’ve yet to answer.
This sistah moment is more than a stranger pointing out you have tissue on your shoe, because it’s usually attached to a call to be a “better” black woman. Maybe it comes from a genuine desire to try and inspire positive change in a fellow sister, to make her the best version of herself. Or maybe it’s even to provide the kind of support system that sadly isn’t always present in our community. You don’t have to look any further than online commenters to see the venom others can fling at virtual strangers. So maybe in her mind, this bride-to-be was telling me something she was afraid my white boss would later use against me. She was protecting me, her sister, and promising to give me the tools I needed to do better.
Yet in this type of sistah moment, Sistah #2 rarely leaves the conversation feeling empowered. In my case, I felt betrayed and exposed. Who is this stranger to tell me I’m making every black person look bad because of a hairstyle? That my desire to “go natural” would get in the way of my success or scooping up a man? Has she never had a bad hair day? Does being black mean you can say whatever you want?
That same skinship also allows for the connection felt during another type of sistah moment, something my coco Dear Abby might have experienced in her corporate world populated by white people. Picture this:
Scene: Office break room during lunch
Mike, a co-worker of yours who looks like he’s always two seconds away from tapping a keg, strolls in and sits at the lunch table.
“You won’t believe the customer I just got off the phone with. He sounded real Ninth Ward-y. Like, ‘Yo dawg, I needs ta get paid!’” Mike flashes approximations of gang signs and laughs.
You are sitting across from a black coworker you rarely speak to. You both raise an eyebrow and shake your heads.
Here, your skin color (which often creates a shared pool of experiences) creates a connection in the face of ignorance. It happens when Becky says she looks black after acquiring a deep tan in Cabo San Lucas. It’s also there when there’s a heated discussion over President Obama’s “socialist” policies. Both women walk away from these moments recognizing that there is someone else who understands their unique position in society; they have an equal part in the experience. No one is better or worse and neither stakes a claim in the others’ life.
“Girl,” that shared glance says. “I know exactly what you’re thinking.”
Black women have an understanding and kinship few other races can even begin to approach. No one can knock you down or raise you up quite like a fellow sistah can.
By the way, I never got an email from the bride after following up on her registry questions and asking for the numbers she offered….bitch. But if we both ever found ourselves in the same room, having to answer questions about our hair or defending the actions of Kelly William-Bolar to a white audience, I’m sure we’d have another sistah moment. Only this time, hopefully we’d be on the same side.
Have you had your own “sistah moments”? Share them with us!
Something similar to your office scene happened to me the other day.
I was taking the train and there was another Black woman, probably around my age waiting with an Asian woman that was with her. Then, came in these loud Black teens that started laughing loudly, cursing, rudely cutting in front of people, and everyone else seemed to look or glance and continue waiting for the train. Somehow me and her both looked at each other shaking our heads. I’m not a psychic, but I’m sure she was thinking “They just had to be black” or “it’s always us”, or something along those lines about Blacks living out the stereotypes. And that’s what I thought of. She made a gesture and it was obvious we were thinking the same thing.
And I’ve had a lot if experiences with the “representatives”. Day to day and online. But i do t wanna explain it. Very nice article.
Back in college, I loved how me and the only other black person in class would turn to each other and smirk like “did you hear that foo?” after something ignorant/naive was said on the topic of race.
I also love the black people nod that we give each other when outside of our “element”.
Yesssss! @ this post! High 5 @ Belle’s comment! I had an Introduction to African Studies class in college and the white people in there were the absolute WORST– referring to Africans as barbaric, primitive, etc. The side eyes were countless… We took turns in addressing the foolishness… and ultimately, worked in solidarity to educate our counterparts.
I’ve have a few of these moments where “elders” or other seemingly successful black folks have tried to school me on representing my race properly. I’ve never appreciated it and pretty much tell them that, in a nice way of course, their opinion means nothing to me and to please take that to someone more impressionable.
Conversely, what if I, as a fit woman that eats well and works out/runs 5-6 times a week, went up to overweight black women and suggested they get right with their health and weight cause obesity and heart disease and diabetes is rampant in African Americans and if I couldn’t tell them, who could? I’d probably get my a*s told off (rightly so) and be labeled a a fat bigot/fat phobic. She could be completely healthy, proud of her body, and doing things to help the community that I only dream about doing. In short, people need to keep their 2 cents to themselves when it comes to the “constructive criticism” of strangers.
We should have those sista moments to help all of us stay on point. To encourage us and for support. I love it. I’ve had to talk with a few interns about showing up to the office (an all black company, thank you) in ultra-short skirts, flip flops and spaghetti strapped tops. Look, I believe in being polished and professional. Period. I’ve seen plenty of very professional women wearing natural styles and look amazing and pulled together. To tell you the truth, I get more compliments when my hair is natural from Mr. Charlie than I do from black folks. Black folks give me grief for my edges not being straight enough. We are afraid of what they might think and their perception of us (which is sad), when frankly, i don’t think Mr. charlie spends that much time thinking about our hair. As far as I’m concerned, every professional woman – natural or permed – should present herself well. Period. So, if having those sista talks help to achieve this, then let’s keep having them. It’s all in presentation.
I’ve experienced the sistah moments in the work place as a young professional. At several jobs, I’ve had high level black woman who would give me the once over, a good sistah-to-sistah talking to, to look the part. These executives would then select white girl/s to mentor who didn’t have half the brain power. Usually the black executive had a perm/wig, make-up, perfumed up. Most of my life I’ve been natural, no make-up but put together.
As a professional, I make it my business to have real sistah talks with the hoopla and the amens.
Without the hoopla and amens
Anthonia, you knocked it out of the park with this one! Keep it up, I love to read what you have to say!
I really liked this post.
I remember considering playing the older, concerned sistah when seeing a group of high school girls dressed like, well, hookers (I’m not exaggerating) on a Sat afternoon, but I chose to keep my mouth shut because I didn’t want a confrontation to ruin my day.
I felt bad about saying nothing, because I do feel a responsibility towards other sisters. There’s a fine line between being compassionate/concerned, and being intrusive, and I’m frankly not quite sure what it is. Good think piece.
Well that is when sista moments are needed. Two high school girls came into my family’s shop. They were asking for donations for a trip or something. Why did one have a shirt that said F*CK big and bold across her chest?
She got a triple sista moment as me, my mum and aunt schooled her, nicely of course, we told her to pick a shirt out the store and we called the school and encouraged them to either have guidelines for what students wore or make them wear their uniforms while out trying to raise money.
Especially when it’s a blatant error like a minor wearing something vulgar we should step in.
We need sistah moments on a daily basis, people. With shows like Saturday Night Live parodying black women, and Martin Lawrence, Big Mama stuff – face it, it’s us against them. So if we can do something to inform one another in a non-confrontational way, then let’s do it. I don’t think the bride-to-be handled it as delicately as she could have. Black women: just because White America likes an “ethnic look,” doesn’t mean that we need to give it to them. The more wild we look the more acceptable the stereotype. So, hey, represent. Represent.
Wild?
“The Ethnic look”? Do you mean ‘looking the way our Creator intended’? Because reading/hearing an African American woman refer to her God given good looks as “wild” and “ethnic” sounds uneducated and silly to me.
Great post! I’m glad this was a addressed. It lends insight into the heterogeneity of blackness and black womanhood. I have these moments as Sistah #2 with older black women. They make my ass itch. The thing about sistah moments is that they do almost always work in the face of outsiders white people and in some cases black men. Where sistah moments go wrong is when we assume that just because we are black and female that we are the same and that we have the same interests. There are still many possible differences among us such as class, career sexuality, gender, religion, disability, etc. This doesn’t mean that there shouldn’t be sistah moments, but if there are they should be encouraging, empowering, and sensitive. And at worst they should educational and inquisitive. Criticism doesn’t necessarily precede understanding.
Exaxtly, The woman assumed the other woman didn’t know what to do wit her hair, when in fact she did. She went natural. Also, I’d like to add definitions of beauty as a difference among black women. We don’t all have the same definitions of beauty. I consider my natural hair just as beautiful as anyone’s straight hair.
I also think that sometimes these “sistah moments” are more often my women to be malicious…because I would never go up to a woman (of any race) and ask who did her hair AND give her the number of my stylist. That would be murder, because what I would really mean is that your hair looks jacked up and go to this place to get it fixed.
It used to happen to me all the time in my social work program in college. I was one of three black people in the program. I had most of my classes with the other black girl in the program. We had so many sistah moments for some of the ridiculous things people said. But during one class our white teacher directly asked how black people (as a whole) felt about a subject. The other guy in my class just looked at me and shook his head. He later told me he did not know what he would say, if he would have actually answered this teachers question. But he never had to say it to me, the way he looked at me in the class said it all.
Well lord I’m in japan and I was trying to explain to my friends the exact same thing, they’re all diff nationalities, but I was noting that the black chicks (and men) DON’T want to have a moment. This is the first time in my life that I’ve never had that connection whether it be scene 1 or 2 with another black woman. Sistahs be actin funky out here.
That stated in a scene one situation I’m usually told off about my hair (natural) or informed I should wear makeup (bad skin) cause I’m not looking polished (aka video girl?) enough. Gotta love the sistahs who care
I’m feeling the same thing here in California.
Black people here don’t want to be black – they are too concerned that the whites (or Japanese in your case) won’t like it or will feel uncomfortable. So they try to make as little waves as possible and if that means forgoing the Black People Acknowledgement Nod to fit in with the whites – then so be it.
Often times those black people grew up around more whites than blacks. So that sense of community you looking for – well gyurl – you eh go find it because they never experienced it and they scared to experience it with you and themselves.
I feel guilty saying this but, I’ve just taken to ignoring them, as they tend to be more condescending than helpful anymore. I can’t tell you how many black women and men for that matter came up to me, this is strangers on the street, 6 mos after I had my baby to give me “tips” on how to flatten my belly, or how to straighten my hair, or how to discipline my children, or appropriate hair removal. I’m frankly tired of “sistah” moments, they are usually more negative than positive in my experience.
See, I’m the type of person who might look at another sistah’s head, see that it is in desperate need of a comb (and I see that in my natural sis’s JUST as often as I see it in the ones with the flowing tangled weave), but I’d never say anything.
Cant say I think she’s wrong for being so forward. I woulda took her on the up and up until I saw she wasn’t planning to send those numbers anyway. That was a dick move.