Last summer I read Demetria Lucas’ book A Belle In Brooklyn: The Go-to-Girl for Advice on Living Your Best Single Life. While I thoroughly enjoyed her hilarious take on her dating life throughout the years (and filed away some of her advice for later use), one chapter gave me pause: Weighty Matters.
In ‘Weighty Matters?’ Lucas deals with a very big problem (no pun intended) plaguing women—especially Black women—our weight.
She writes: “I’ve been wondering for a while if the collective weight of Black women is affecting our ability to pair off. And by weight, I mean the numbers on the scale, not our emotional baggage, although for some of us, that is heavy, too.
I can’t help but notice that in nearly every run-down of what it is that Black men are looking for in a Black woman, weight inevitably sneaks into onto the list, usually in the form of “she works out” or “she stays fit” or “she is concerned about her health or personal appearance”—i.e., she’s not fat.
As someone who’s always had a “plus” in front of my size, reading that kind of stung.
Growing up, I was always the chubby, shy girl. Throughout the years, I’ve (mostly) shed my shyness and my weight has redistributed itself to be on par with my height, but I still live very much on the “voluptuous” side of town (that picture is close to what I look like naked). In the past—college—I didn’t really care. I was confortable with myself and I was still attractive to others, so being “thick” didn’t bother me, and as a matter of fact, I wore it with pride.
These days, however, as I’m firmly grown and not as active as I used to be, I can’t help but think that perhaps my weight is holding me back from meeting “the one.” Sure, I meet men all of the time, several of whom tell me I’m beautiful and sexy. But for one reason or another, some of these men just don’t do it for me. They’re nice enough, not assholes, employed, but I’m not physically attracted to them. But, chile…the ones that do cause my pressure to rise? At times I wonder if they’re not giving me a second look because my stomach isn’t flat and I have a little extra roundness to my thighs.
Admittedly, I partake in double standards.
While some might consider me “a big girl,” I’m not really attracted to “big” guys. I like men with athletic, strong bodies. Not by any means “perfect” or extra-cut, but not Rick Ross style either (your tits can’t be bigger than mine, sorry).
But how can I be so picky about a man’s body while expecting him to overlook mine?
While I’m all for women embracing their bodies—which I do—I’m also not about promoting unhealthiness. While big is indeed beautiful, it can also kill you (just like being too thin is unhealthy as well). If you can’t walk up a few flights of stairs without nearly having an asthma attack, something has got to change (and that goes for everyone–”big” or “small”).
But should you make those changes solely to find love?
I struggle with this all the time. While I’m currently reforming my health to be the best Britni I can be, I’d be lying if I didn’t admit I’m also trying to drop a few pounds in the hopes that it will not only improve my health, but also increase my access to a wider selection of men.
But am I being superficial or smart? And should weight even matter?
What do you think…has your weight and/or body helped or hurt your chances to get boo’d up?
Originally published on WhoYouCallinABitch.com
I like thick women. You are only being hypocritical if you don’t entertain suitors in the same physical shape that you are in. The Rick Ross tit thing, I can understand. But if you want a “hard body” you likely will need one yourself. I’m certain that, in your perusal of “girlie advice” materials like the book mentioned you’ve heard the expression, “You gotta BE the thing that you SEEK”. I know that thought is quite prevalent in “law of attraction” materials. If it isn’t in the female advice materials, it should be. IJS…
You should make the changes because YOU want to.
Let me say this: meeting the “right one” is a numbers game. You are going to meet men who want to have sex, some who want a relationship, and some who want to put a ring on it. Some men like big girls, some men don’t. Plain and simple. Don’t settle for nonsense. At the end of the day, it’s about the guy who treats you like you should be treated: royalty.
Everything else is just stuff we allow society to dictate to us. I know plenty of plus size women who are happily married to great, loving and handsome men.
I know my wife is.
sad but perhaps true. I used to be a hardcore gym bunny and lost over 50lbs that i had be holding on to most of my teen years. at the point (even more so than usual) guys we interested. this was a clear distinction because I am referring to mostly to black men that I had known for years or met previously. suddenly I had captured their interest. only i didnt want it. during this time i started dating for the first time. I soon found myself married and 3 years later I am happy but due to lifestyle changes the weight is back and then some. of course i want to get back on track for health purposes but i cringe at the comments “thank God you found a husband before you found those lbs you lost?”
Are we twins? Same story over here, including the weight gain and subsequent comments. I know they are cringe-worthy, but you must concede that there is some truth to them.
I wouldn’t have found my husband had I not been in the headspace and physically ideal place I was when I was a gymrat. Being fit was a huge part of my life and aided my self-esteem. You couldn’t tell me nuthin’ when I was finally slender. And that is who my man fell in love with. Thankfully, my 40 pound weight gain took years, so he didn’t feel like I pulled a “bait and switch,” but we both know I ain’t acting (or looking) like I used to.
So, the day after Thanksgiving (not “after the holidays”, NO.) I got my but back to the gym and changed my eating. It’s been a little over a week and I’m 8 lbs. down. I ain’t playing. No excuses.
And I ain’t trying to keep my man with this. I want to keep myself.
You should absolutely do it. I am I used to be a size 7. Now I am a 12-14. I was weighting 207 on july 4. I Now weight 187. I am doing it mostly to get married to a guy I am attracted to and of course for my health. Plus I want to wear a bikini come this summer. I want to lose 50 more pounds. You should do what your heart desires. If you want that attractive man, you have to do what you have to do. I hope more black women realize this.
Great read! I just visited the doctors office a few weeks ago and I weighed in a 196lbs!!!!! Needless to say I was in complete shock. The first thing the doctor said to me was “what are we gonna do about your weight” ? I almost cried..
First off I don’t look it at all!! I could use a few months of strength training, portion control and Ill be good but I still will be at 170-180 range once I tighten up.
Now also my doctor told me not to be soo pressed to loose too much weight because of genetics ( being of African descent). This is the first time a doc has said that to me.Most of the push that BMI bull crap. ( it makes no sense).
I’m really starting to consider getting my muscle mass measured as well because I dont have much excess fat. Maybe its my body build or frame.
Now as far as relationships, I have been as small as 135 ( low body fat and low muscle mass) when I was in a long term relationship at 17 yrs old my boyfriend told me to gain weight because I wasn’t as curvy as when I met him. ( I was under alot of stress with him and my weight dropped like crazy).
Haven’t been in a relationship since then ( Im now 23) but I have no problem attracting men and being asked out on dates. However my confidence is in limbo alot because I AM body conscious about what I should look like.
I have yet to find a happy medium, but I wont stop searching…….neither should you!!!
I have so many friends who are overweight. We are in our 30s and I am the only one who is married. They all want to be married; they all have men, but never have long term relationships and I do think that their weight has something to do with it.
With that being said, they are all fun, bubbly and display confidence, but deep down they hate their weight. And constantly complain about not being able to drop pounds. These are also women who eat out EVERYDAY. Big meals, huge portions.
I also think that their weight hides their beauty.
The question is, “But should you make those changes solely to find love?” Yes, they should. The are secretly miserable and personally, I believe that their weight is preventing them from dating the “right” men.
On the other hand, I am skinny and I also heard a similar phrase from BM, “You are so pretty, just no butt.” Luckily, my husband likes small butts (but he is white).
Also, too many women confuse men stating that they like women with meet on their bones with fat. I dont think many men prefer fat.
Not necessarily, but it’s not like this article is helping.
I agree- you can’t really expect to be pulling gym raps if you’re not one yourself. Yet that somehow doesn’t apply as much to men seeking women. Hey there, double standard.
Being fat is not a surefire sign of unhealthiness. Smoking is, however.
I know its a thin line between being honest, dishing out much needed constructive criticism and penning the same old memes to women who need a new perspective that actually take them into consideration, but this piece is stomping all over the “Change this this this about you, wretched black woman, and get a man!” side.
If you your healthy, does your weight hold you back? Maybe, but I’m willing to bet that all those preconceived notions about your weight hold you back even more.
Great points Kaydee!
@Feri,
I could not agree with you more. I am 28 year old black female, in a relationship with a 31 year old black man and I know that he’d rather have curvy woman than not. We’ve been together for 13 years now, through 2 babies and subsequent weight fluctuations on my part and his. But it blows my mind how he constantly says he would lose his mind if I “lost” my butt. He is THE quintessiential black man who loves a big butt.
It’s funny though because when I started losing weight, and was losing a little bit back there he couldn’t keep his hands off of my entire body. But was quick to say that I was losing too much in my thighs/butt. I’ve put a little of that weight back on (belly included unfortunately) and now it’s all about my butt and nothing else, the rest of me gets no love at all! Lol.
It had me confused for a while but I figured at the end of the day, yes, I think black men want a little meat in the right places but still overall want a firm toned body. But… if there’s a woman who’s overweight leaving her with an exaggerated backside, they will be okay honing in on just that one outstanding body part, although I don’t think that’s the winning preference of not only black men but men in general.
And to flip the situation I don’t think I’d want the flabby guy who’s “packin’ down there” over the guy who’s pretty fit and is not “humungous” but knows how to get the job done. Only reason being with the former is for that one area and while that may or may not be fun, (ouch), it would get old fast.
My opinion, total package/fit trumps mammoth ass and tits.
I’ve known some women that I thought were very pretty or cute but were just too damned big. If they lost the weight the I probably would have approached them but for most it didn’t happen. It really comes down to a question of health and h/w proportion.
Have I had sex with big women as a jump off, yep, but in terms of long term dating I’ve only ever done it once, otherwise the women had bodies that suited them. Some were skinny some were big but what they had worked for them.
So yes, you can be too big to attract some men, and deflections, straw man, arguments, personal attacks on men, etc. don’t work in the long term in terms of what they like don’t work because men do the approaching. Calling yourself a BBW just because you’re overweight doesn’t make it so no matter how much energy is used as a group to get men to change what they like or in trying to get a specific man to like you.
As an aside, the smoking deflection that was used earlier in the comments is a terrible example as issues regarding overweight and obese people cause more health issues than smokers.
That’s cleared my thoughts. Thanks for conrtbiuting.
GmXPSm drkohemnfcie
ED1l7m rgzlmftvwchr
I think that people shouldn’t really force themselves to lose weight just to increase their chances of having a life life. This is because nowadays, many women like big guys and there are also several men who love big women. So, don’t change because if he really loves you, he will accept you as you are.