If you had to name the biggest problems facing America right now, would you say unemployment and foreclosures? Perhaps education, international relations, or our military presence abroad? Well, the Republican Party is convinced that yet another abortion bill is more pressing than any of these, and this one is intended to save the black community from itself.

Representative Trent Franks (R-Ariz., pictured) is sponsoring the Susan B. Anthony and Frederick Douglass Prenatal Nondiscrimination Act of 2011, or PRENDA. The bill seeks to “prohibit discrimination against the unborn on the basis of sex or race,” and will criminalize the failure of medical professionals to investigate whether women are aborting their babies on those bases.

In other words, any woman pregnant with what may be a black or female fetus can only be granted an abortion if her doctor is sure that she’s not seeking the abortion simply because the fetus is black or female. This would mean at the very least a series of questions aimed at any black woman seeking an abortion, and at worst the reluctance of doctors to treat certain patients at all for fear of prosecution.

At a Tuesday hearing, Franks called the fight to give female and minority babies the same right to life as white male babies the “civil rights struggle that will define our generation,” and presented well-worn anti-choice statistics likening the abortion rates among black women to genocide. Keep in mind that Franks is the same representative who once argued that, because of the disproportionally high rate of abortion in the black community, African-Americans were better off during slavery.

In response, the NAACP and 46 other civil rights groups wrote a letter explaining that it’s access to pregnancy prevention, not discrimination against unborn children, that causes black women to have a higher rate of unplanned pregnancy than white women (67% and 40%, respectively). Instead of stripping women of their right to choose, they argue, the answer is to arm women with the information and resources that will help them prevent unwanted pregnancies in the first place. They further argued that not only does gender discrimination play no role in American abortion statistics, the problem of black women who have abortions because they are pregnant with black babies is blatantly nonexistent.

Representative John Conyers (D-Mich), who has served in the House since 1964 and is one of the founding members of the Congressional Black Caucus, openly asked why the memories of two of Americas most significant civil rights leaders are being used to promote the bill by saying “I know more about Frederick Douglass than you do and he didn’t say anything about prenatal discrimination.”

I’m no Frederick Douglass scholar, but I’m pretty sure he’s right.

Is this bill really meant to help the black community? Or has the Republican Party finally outdone itself with the faulty logic in this one? 



  • Kaypee

    Why does the government get to decidewhat goes on in a woman’s uterus? Stay the f**k out!

  • http://www.sayjerve.storenvy.com Charise

    What? Lawd Im so confused.

  • Mimi

    I was thinking the exact same thing. When it comes to what I want to do with my body, I don’t need any politician’s help on that.

  • http://@clnmike Clnmike

    Somebody was drinking when they thought this gem up.

  • http://cupofjo-jo.blogspot.com bk chick

    Umm where are all these ppl AFTER the fetus is born?? truth is there is a reason why there are a disproportionate amount of minority ppl who get abortions and this is directly linked to the quality of life the unborn child is percieved to have. The best way to stop abortion is not to make it Illegal but to raise the quality of life among all people across the board, including a focus on education and lowering the income gap etc. If anyone is interested in looking at some interesting stats about abortion, please read freakonomics…and only if you don’t get easily offended..

  • Timcampi

    But we’re free to abort all the white male fetuses right? Cause as a feminist that totally aligns with my mission in life.

    *eye-rolling sarcasm*

  • Chica

    I just can’t get over the name of the bill. As if giving an anti-choice bill the name “Susan B. Anthony and Frederick Douglass Prenatal Nondiscrimination Act of 2011″ will make me think that it has the best interest of women and black folks in mind. Give me a break.

  • http://changecomesslow.com/2011/12/07/abortion-the-true-black-on-black-crime-the-word-no-part-10/ Nikesha

    This bill is a mess. Not only is it illegal because it is discriminatory it still doesn’t solve the problem of reducing abortion in Black communities.

    Let’s be clear, banning abortion will not stop abortions, just like prohibition did not stop alcohol consumption, and the war on drugs has not stopped the proliferation of marijuana, meth, cocaine and crack on city streets. Telling people “no” will not change their behavior. Giving people an alternative to… or the education of… is the only way to route behavior in a different direction for a more positive or the desired outcome.

  • LKJ

    I am so tired of these anti-choice people trying to take away women’s rights. Republicans are so concerned with forcing women to keep their baby’s yet refuse to do anything about the tough situation thes women and their kids are facing. They want to get rid of TANF, do away with food stamps, get rid of child labor laws and put kids as young as 9 to work.

  • AI


  • AJ

    I was thinking the same thing..it’s Comical
    What will they think of next?

  • d_nicegirl

    So annoyingly and unabashedly disingenuous.

  • QON

    There are huge gender imbalances in places like India and China because couples do abort based on the gender of the baby. That gender being female. Some have called it gendercide. Before you guys sneer at this bill ( though is a bit odd in American since there seems to be a preference for female children anyway) you guys should consider the MILLIONS of baby girls that have been killed in and out of the womb because they werent born with penises.

  • Duke

    …and India and China will not be effected by this bill. So, sneer? No. Side eye? Yes.

  • B

    LOL. Right?! Jeez, the republicans really are cra-cra. I guess Lewis Black had it right when he described the repubs as the party of “bad ideas” and the dems as the party of “no ideas.” What’s wrong with these ridiculous politicians?

  • B

    Representative John Conyers’ statement is absolutely priceless and pretty much captures my response to this bill. Smh. These politicians are absolute headcases.

  • Misty Jean

    Thank you! These are the same people who say Democrats want to keep blacks dependent on the government with welfare and food stamps. Hello, when you force poor young women to have unwanted children, someone is going to have to raise them.

  • Misty Jean

    So black American women should have female babies because Chinese and Indian parents don’t want theirs? I’m confused. What will this bill do to help gender discrimination in poor countries?

  • E.M.S.

    The republican party is out of control. What on earth makes them think black women are terminating because the child is black or female? They do it because the pregnancy was unwanted, not because the child is a certain color or has a certain set of genitalia.

    Instead of focusing so much on abortion, they need to be focusing on the availability of resources to prevent unwanted pregnancy in the first place. But oh wait, they’re trying to get rid of Planned Parenthood, which DOES THAT. Morons, the lot of them.

    Let’s also remember that unwanted pregnancy is not some epidemic solely among black women, it happens to women of all ethnicities.

  • http://www.facebook.com/Libra2008 April

    WTF? I seriously doubt the government is trying to help BLACK women but instead try to choose how we make decisions. Even if a black woman wants to have an abortion for those reasons, have they not decided on what basis white women abort their babies? It’s always something with the government and the black community! Clearly, I believe a woman should be able to decide what happens with her body, black or white. Would I abort my baby, no, but if someone wants, then maybe they’ll have safer sex next time, but it’s still THEIR decision. The whole debate that “children should have a shot at this life too” is ludicrous because aborting a fetus is no different than a woman having her uterus taken out, taking the morning after pill, or going through menopause being that our eggs are ALL potential babies that may not have “a shot at this life.”

  • Simone

    LIke we really need the far right looking out for black people?? Anyone remember slavery?

Latest Stories

Brooklyn DA Proposes to Stop Prosecuting Low-Level Marijuana Charges


The Doc Is In: Doc McStuffins Encourages Little Girls to Embrace Their Natural Hair


The FCC Gave The Internet A Big Middle Finger


5 Spring Beauty and Style Tips

Read previous post:
Tameka Raymond: “‘Undercover Gay Guys’ Should Wear a Bright Wristband”
5 Men And Women On The Dating Scene We All Hate