23

Is Saying I Love You A Relationship Requirement?

Wednesday Jan 25, 2012 – by

I love you: two nouns and one verb, three words, a daring phrase. It attempts to express one of the deepest emotions ever known to man. It’s layered with vulnerability, void of egotism, and raw in human truth. To say “I love you” is to speak a challenge to practice love as an action and give unconditionally to family, friends, partners, and lovers. But without reciprocity as a given, we often struggle to tell all of the people who influence our lives and inspire our hearts that yes, we love them. When it comes to lovers with whom we have no “official” relationship, saying, “I love you,” often feels like a guaranteed way to commit emotional suicide. But is it really? Or just another defense mechanism that’s developed into a human shortcoming?

When there’s no “security” in any human relationship, we often hold back from giving our whole selves to certain individuals as protection from potential heartbreak. But as love continues to prove that there are very few rules, it’s a wonder that many of us still get caught up in the politics of when and how to express positive love instead of allowing it to flow freely and in truth.

Of course, love has many different manifestations and can apply numerous human relationships. Romantic love is not even a fixed definition or entity. But most of us know love when we feel it, and we react by succumbing to the urge to box it, suppress it, and control it.

It’s the ego that tells us that love has to come in a certain prototype, neatly packaged to fit our fantasies. If he’s not a soon-to-be husband or boyfriend, he isn’t worth our love, affection, or confession. If she’s not our soon-to-be girlfriend, she isn’t worthy of the courage for us to be raw with our feelings and emotions that indicate that love has taken a presence in our lives. If it hasn’t been six months or a year, we refuse to let the phrase slide off our lips. We rather not express our emotions. We put on our poker faces and entertain denial.

Human beings have been trying for centuries, and we still have failed to rationalize or understand love. It’s never served us to set our hearts and minds up for battle against each other. By always trying to intellectualize love instead of just feeling it, we have built all this hype and pressure around one of the sweetest human actions: saying what you’re doing anyway. You are loving. There’s no need to feed your fears.

As always, words are choices. And it is best to use them wisely. But if love is one of the saving graces of humanity and backbone of any healthy human connection, why do we hesitate to introduce it as a phrase to our lovers that don’t fit traditional relationship models?

Do you need to be in a relationship to feel comfortable enough to tell a lover that you love them even if you already feel it? Or are you one to say what’s on your heart regardless of a relationship status? Speak on it.

23 Comments – Add Yours

  1. avatar Jayne Dirt says:

    Nice article. I think an integral part of being in love is the ability to be vulnerable…if you can’t articulate it, then maybe you don’t really love…just a thought.

    Being in Brasil….Salvador specifically has shown me what love is all over again…Even more the cultural differences in expressing it. Has living among different cultures and observing how they exhibit love to one another shifted your perspective about it?

    • avatar Are You Serious Bro says:

      Hmm, I have to respectfully disagree with that.

      I think showing the emotion of love outweighs how much one articulates it. So many people say that they love, but so few really show it with their actions. I would much rather have a women who might be shy about saying it, but has no problems displaying it, then for the opposite to be true.

      I think Anthony David and Indie Arie said it best in their duet “Words”

      “Can’t tell you nothin you aint already heard
      No matter what I say it’s nothin but words
      Just let me prove to you what I know is real
      Let me express to you the way that I feel”

      Great post by the way Arielle

      *sneaks out before somebody sees me*

    • avatar LemonNLime says:

      @Are You Serious Bro – “I think showing the emotion of love outweighs how much one articulates it.” When I was younger I would disagreed with you but as I have gotten older I find that to be very true.

      I find that in English, “love” is a word that is used all the time because we don’t really have other words to substitute it. You love you parents, you love your partner, your love the Sox, you love your dog, you love pizza. While each then may make you feel a certain way differently you use one word to describe it all. This is why I think it is so easy for people to say “I love you” even when they really mean “I really like you”.

      I find that being able to show it is much more important for me. My Dad is very stoic and introverted and my Mom is really loud and outgoing. I never understood how they work out when my Mom was always saying “I love you” and my Dad would just kinda mumble back. He was the same with me and my sister. But my Mom explained to me that he showed his love in other ways working everyday to support his family, taking care of us when we were sick, helping pay for college, providing us with all the things we needed, helping us with homework, defending us when needed, etc. That is how my Dad showed his love for his family rather through words because that is how his father showed his love for his family.

      It doesn’t take much to say the words “love” but to show it day after day (for 29 years for my parents), that is work. I find I am much more like my Dad when it comes to saying “I love you” and while I would love a man that could both say and show it, I think I would choose someone who could show it rather than say it.

    • avatar Tumaini says:

      I think all of your comments (Jayne, Are You Serious Bro, and LemonNLime) demonstrate that different people simply have different needs in terms of feeling loved. Some of us need to hear those three words, and for others, acts of love suffice without the verbalization. I think each partner has to adapt to the other’s needs where this is concerned. I think the book “The Five Love Languages” by Gary Chapman explains this beautifully and would recommend it to all!

    • @Tumaini, I was thinking of the SAME EXACT book when I wrote my comment, but I figured not everyone would know what I was talking about so I left that out of my comment :)

  2. avatar fuchsia says:

    I speak my heart and mind regardless of relationship status. I find that it’s easy to love someone who I respect and see as a friend first. If he becomes my lover it’s usually because I love him. Great Article!

  3. avatar Kaila says:

    Very well written

  4. I think that some people feel the need to say/hear it, and others do not. It depends on how you want love to be expressed to you. As long as you can find someone who can communicate to you in the way you need them to, you are good.

  5. avatar Melissa says:

    Interesting article. From personal experience, telling someone you love them when there’s no “official” status between you can make things extremely awkward and uncomfortable. You have to be very aware of the possible consequences. On the other hand, if you’re sure they feel the same way, why not go for it. I first told my boyfriend that I loved him after we’d only been dating for about two months. He said he wasn’t sure how he felt and I responded “you love me, you just don’t know it yet”. Lucky for me I was right but some people are not as fortunate. Perhaps a wise way to go about dropping the big L is to feel out the situation, assess your risks and go from there. If it feels right, and you won’t regret saying it, go for it. If not, hold back and see where it goes.

    I agree with @girlformerlyknownasgrace that some people need to hear it when others don’t. Those people typically require some sort of validation that can only come from others. To them being told they are loved is the greatest gift they can receive.

    Regardless, great article!

  6. avatar African Mami says:

    I’ve NEVER used that word outside of my nuclear family and my dogs! I am not one that is sentimental. I’m what you call affectionately aloof!

  7. avatar LuvIt289 says:

    Great article :-)
    Sigh! <3 <3 <3
    I had to realize that being in love doesn't necessarily mean looking at guidelines. Everyone is different. Probably the only similarity is you must be "open".
    Love is putting your ego to the side, and excepting another person that will see you at your best&worst, and vice versa.

    But let me stop. I'm going through^^^the above^^^ right now and this article is just on time for me! :-)

  8. avatar lw says:

    Great post. I struggled with this for years. My bf never said it, so I didn’t say it, and my resentment grew and grew. Finally I confronted him. Turns out he believes in showing rather than telling. And that man has loved every part of me (inside and out) since the beginning.
    At some point you have to get over the fairytales we were force-fed. I’d rather have my man show me love than say it often with nothing really behind the words. Feeling loved is what is important to me.

  9. avatar CD86 says:

    It wouldn’t be a requirement for me.

    If you are like me, someone who grew up in an environment where a person’s word meant nothing because they never came through with their actions, someone merely telling you something holds no weight.

    Additionally, it can depend on the person’s personality as well. Some people are just more vocal about their emotions than others.

    *Why do Clutch writers write so many articles about relationships? Not everyone has extensive relationship experience.*

  10. avatar sweetpisces says:

    I think it’s just as important to say it out loud as proving it..as long as you don’t say it too soon. I rather wait until i’m sure about the other’s feelings and usually until he says it first. lol i’m just saying.

  11. avatar CD86 says:

    I wish my comment would show up.

  12. [...] Saying I Love You, Is A Relationship A Requirement? « The Sex-Positive Black Woman /* [...]

  13. avatar mahogany says:

    Love is an action verb. Therefore saying I love you without actually showing love means nothing.

  14. avatar chinaza says:

    Well some people need to hear it and others don’t. People are very different in terms of their emotional needs.

  15. avatar Jen says:

    Yes, it is. Next question.

  16. avatar Aaron B says:

    How did this get by the editor? “I” and “you” are pronouns, not nouns.

Leave a Comment

  • We moderate comments and prohibit personal attacks, threats, spam, lewd images, or the promotion of your personal website.
  • Please keep comments related to topic.
  • Follow us on Facebook and Twitter.

You are commenting as a Guest. Optional: Login below.

Daily Blog - News.Gossip.Info