Do We Still Need Black Leaders?

by Britni Danielle

African Americans are not a monolith, however, there are many things that bind us together despite class, education, or income level. Racism, the struggle for equal opportunity to education, heath care, and how we are viewed in America and abroad are still issues many of us struggle with. Because of this, some have wondered if we need more “black leaders” reminiscent of Malcolm or Martin, folks who will authentically champion our causes across this country and the world.

After the civil rights movement and the assassinations of many outspoken black activists, some have wondered if our perceived lack of leadership has caused African Americans to lose ground. On the other hand, others argue that no one “leader” can speak for the concerns of black folks in this country.

Recently, writer and political activist Kevin Powell wondered whether or not black leaders are dead. In his article, “Black leadership is dead. Long live black leadership,” Powell challenges the notion that we no longer need leaders, but rather asserts that we need more of them…in all areas.

He writes:

It may look as though Black America has fallen into a terrible rut around our leadership today, but that’s in part because a faulty image—that of the singularly powerful national black leader—has been perpetuated out of the upheavals of the Civil Rights Movement. Yet Dr. King was never the lone leader of Black America in his day. There was Fannie Lou Hamer, Dorothy Height, Malcolm X, Ella Baker and a wide range of women and men of various ages and backgrounds.

A quick scan of American history finds many other national black leaders coexisting in the same eras, be it Sojourner Truth, Harriet Tubman and Frederick Douglass during the abolitionist movement, or Ida B. Wells, Booker T. Washington and W.E.B DuBois during the anti-racism efforts around the turn of the 20th century. But in the 1970s and 1980s, as integration and black class division began taking root, as the devastating effects of drugs began to plague our inner cities, and as conservatives began trying to erase the very minimal civil rights victories we achieved, black leadership became not only rooted in racial protest, but unable to be self-reflective or self-critical. Embarrassingly, black leaders latched onto this flawed notion of the need for a single national figurehead. They increasingly found themselves at each other’s throats as they jockeyed to be the grand poobahs of Black America.

I agree with Powell. The notion that such a vast and diverse group of people can be summarized by a singular black leader is not only wrong, but also dangerous. Anointing one person “the leader of black America” makes it nearly impossible to criticize them without being viewed as “against” black folks.

Thankfully, black folks across this country have continued to champion the causes of those in their communities. From Steve Perry to Marc Lamont Hill, Cornel West to Tracey Cooper, and many many more, black folks are stepping up, speaking out, and working for change all across this country.

What do you think…do we still need black leaders?

  • Sindy

    Yes, having someone to point us in a positive direction will not hurt. When something of a sociopolitical nature happens, we have the same ol’ Messy Jessie and Al Sharpton.

    While the latter does make some good points on his TVOne program, having someone that is less of a personality who can keep his personal life to himself would be refreshing.

    L.A. has Earl Ofari Hutchison but sometimes he uses media to make a mountain out of a molehill.

  • monique

    If it is a women then maybe but after learning about martine L.king sleeping with white women in my history class. I DO NOT WANT ANOTHER BLACK MALE LEADER.

  • malik hemmans

    r u sure?

  • gryph

    we don’t need leader as much as we need a plan and people who are innovative, engaged yet methodical to execute. leaders can be killed, ideas and skills, not so much. black messianism is the reason why things have been pretty stalled.

  • Greg

    No more LIBERAL Black leaders pleaaase!

  • cake211

    So, you’re saying that the transgressions of one man is enough to demonize the entire black male race? Come on, sonn. What kinda sense does that make? How does Martin Luther King suddenly represent the entire black male race? And why does it matter that it was white women? Would it make any difference if they were black women or men? It’s a shame that you think the sins of a man negate the achievements he made, not just for himself, but for the human race.
    Grow up, please.

  • cake211

    What’s wrong with “liberal” black leaders?

  • Greg

    “What’s wrong with “liberal” black leaders?”

    There not concerned w/ black men or boys. They are only concerned with preserving tax-payer payments to single mothers.

    Or perhaps you’ll like to fill us in on all the progressives things they’re doing for the two:

    Such as eliminating voucher programs for black youth in DC in preference and solidarity with the Teacher’s Union.

    Black liberals advocate for gays and lesbians but I see nothing regarding black males or boys.

    They advocate for black women and girls.

    Do Black men and boys and Fathers not exist?

    Democrats hate men and liberal black leaders are no different.

  • leonard smalls

    Interesting comment; however, allow me to add the following:

    1. No Black Leaders – There are no Black leaders nor have there been any since Malcolm and Martin. Nor will there be one on the horizon anytime soon, see below for clarity.

    2. De Facto Stooges – It is arguable to conclude that any so-called “leader” that the mainstream presents Colored people with can’t be for the benefit of Colored folks because (i) the two groups have completely different sets of problems to solve; and (ii) the two solutions can not coexist.

    3. Therapeutic Politics – Any so called “Black leader” today arguably is guilty of practicing therapeutic politics where one replaces words for deeds. Here, “deeds” refers to the implementation of solutions to Colored people’s utter powerlessness, period.

  • BlacknAmazed

    Rule Number One- In the African American Manual …Don’t believe None of what you learn in your History Class.

    Momma should have told you that. Always seek history for yourself.

    Girl….what evidence did that submit of King with the white women?….LMAO

  • ricoh

    All of you people putting down Mr.Jackson and Mr. Sharpton are typical stupid negative black’s who have never spoken out against injustice in their entire lives,these type of people sit and never say a thing in defensive of another brother or sister.Why don’t any of you people who are talking everbody else, do something your self.Hip Hop aged people are lost ,they need leadership and clear direction.Black folks need to get involved in civil disobedience,and do something.

  • ricoh

    Leadership is always needed,look at are people in this country,too many incarcerations and poverty.We need people who speak out against injustice,and wickedness and unfairness, a lot of you people can sit on your ivory towers and debate the question do we need leadership,while millions of poor black’s are trapped in the poverty maze,and the morally currupt justice system.Heck yeah”, we need leaders.

  • Sharon

    I’m not surprised to hear that a history class would discuss Dr. King in a negative light. This man is a Nobel Peace Prize winner. Powerful Blacks are targets in this country. I’ve learned that you must seek out the truth when it comes to our history. Teaching us to Self-Hate keeps you from supporting those leaders that want to fight for what’s important to you. It keeps us mistrusting each other and at the bottom of the social ladder. We need Black Leaders to stand up for education that prepares our students for high paying jobs and enterprising minds. We need to develop critical thinking skills and stop watching the TV to learn who we are, what we like, what to wear, and gossip about other peoples business. We have a lot of work to do in our communities. We have women who are lost believing they have to dress and behave like whores to be loved. Black women are true Queens who brought up the white leaders in history. We are strong and must respect ourselves in order to recieve respect from our men and the world. Black men are the most powerful creatures on this earth. You are feared by all because with the right mind, education and support you will and can rule this country. In order to stay in control you were fed drugs, alcohol, videos that degrade your women and mothers and sports. You are more than that. We are more than that! As a child my father was military. I was the only black child in my 4th grade class. My white teacher told us that black people were Kings and Queens in Africa. They were stolen from their country and brought to America. She went on to show us pictures of all of the inventions and contributions that blacks made to this country. I have always known who we are. We are people that came from nothing. Our culture and our foundation was stolen from us but we thrive. We need more black leaders to point our people in our rightful direction so we can move forward and upward. I’m praying for us always.

Latest Stories

Why Oiling Your Scalp May Not Be Such A Bad Idea


Nigerian Officials Confirm Release of 44 Abducted School Girls


Watch: ‘Black People Mate’ a Parody About the Ridiculous Stats on Black Women & Dating


University President Under Fire for Wanting to Make School Less White In the Future