When U.S. Sergeant Robert Bales stands trial for the premeditated murder of 17 innocent Afghan civilians, the United States should be right there beside him.

There is no pretty way to say it.

Our government and military leadership murdered them – including 9 women and 3 children – as surely as if they had pulled the trigger themselves.

By all accounts, Bales was a troubled man. On March 11, he left his military base in Southern Afghanistan at 3:00 a.m. walked approximately one mile to a rural village, going door to door shooting and stabbing innocent villagers in their homes. As swiftly as he had come, he turned his back on the carnage and ruined lives and calmly walked back to his base. With his arms raised in surrender, he allegedly confessed to his crimes. For days following the murders, witnesses claimed that there were a few to twenty U.S. soldiers operating with Bales. Of course, their side of the story has been suppressed and Bales awaits trial for crimes that he now claims he “can’t really remember.”

Deployed four times to Iraq and Afghanistan over the past 10 years, Bales lost a foot and suffered a traumatic head injury. During his time away, his family struggled financially and was reportedly on the verge of losing their home. In addition to his personal issues, the night before the massacre, he was present when a close friend’s leg was blown off by a land mine and was later seen drinking on base.

According to reports, he asked and was subsequently assured that he would not be deployed a fourth time, but he was – to disastrous consequences.

Now, we could rehash the numbers.

The 10-20% of soldiers who suffer from PTSD. Or the fact that more U.S. soldiers have committed suicide than have died in combat. We could even discuss why in the hell 57% of soldiers who experienced traumatic brain injury have not been evaluated by a physician.

More specific to this situation, though, is that the U.S. government — initially under the executive power of George W. Bush and now under the leadership of President Barack Obama — repeatedly sends troops into combat in unstable condition and when women are raped, children are murdered and limbs are torn from innocent men, they offer sincere apologies and say that the guilty parties will be punished.

Yet the real guilty parties, our imperialistic government who feels that it’s perfectly normal to murder presidents of sovereign nations in clandestine night raids, bomb schools for Down Syndrome and send drones to blindly massacre innocent children in the “name of war,” continue to make poetic speeches about “progress.”

This is not to say that Robert Bales deserves a pass. To assume that just because a person potentially suffers with mental illness that they are capable of more heinous crimes than the next person is to perpetuate the stigma that surrounds psychological disorders.  It’s my opinion that Bales should receive a full psychological evaluation, and if he is deemed fit for trial and found to be “sane” in the minutes before the killings, he should be found guilty on all charges.

As should the accomplices who sent him back into combat.

“We have traveled through more than a decade under the dark cloud of war. Yet here, in the pre-dawn darkness of Afghanistan, we can see the light of a new day on the horizon.”

Those are the words of President Barack Obama as he stood 7,000 miles away at Bagram Air Base, Afghanistan, to discuss the strategic partnership agreement signed between the United States and Afghan governments. Though the words sound pretty, in a country whose president calls us “disgusting assassins,” what exactly do they mean, Mr. President? We have troops killing women and children in their sleep, taking pictures with and urinating on corpses and burning Qurans — and you say that we can see the light of a new day? I fail to see how the actions of Bale are any different than the crimes carried out in the name of the United States of America every, single day. If our entire system isn’t placed on trial, this will happen again.

Murder is murder is murder – even when it’s draped in a United States flag.


Like Us On Facebook Follow Us On Twitter
  • Sierra Delta

    As a member of the U.S. Armed Forces, I can understand your opinion (you being on the outside looking in) and respect the fact that you have one. Tragedy definitely struck in Afghanistan and bad things will continue to happen in the world, whether the US is involved or not. But, please keep in mind that the American military is made up of an ALL volunteer force. We volunteer to protect the US and we do honorable work day in and day out that is not reported in the news. Maybe you don’t have a military member in your life that can illustrate the sense of pride we take in what we do but rest assured the majority of us are citizen just like you that want to have a positive impact in the lives we touch, American and otherwise. I won’t go into all of the measures the Department of Defense puts in place to make sure we are healthy (mentally, physically, socially, and spiritually) but I can guarantee the investment put into our welfare surpasses what the civilian population receives. At some point each of us, military member or civilian, has to take responsibility for our own actions…You wouldn’t blame the entire Microsoft corporation for one of its employees opening fire in the office…and you can’t blame Virginia Tech for the devastating massacre that occurred on their campus. Being in the military comes with unique stresses, absolutely! No one understands that better that we, the members do, but the choice is OURS to serve.

    • MarloweOverShakespeare

      I thank and appreciate you for your response and your service Sierra Delta. As a part of the Clutch community I salute you.

      As the child of vets, I have a sense of how mentally unstable one can become as a result of serving in a war. Yet my parents still taught me by example a universal truth, that we can only be accountable for our own deeds, and that they all have consequences.

      Have a great morning.

    • Tricia

      Thank you for your comment. After reading the post and the comments after I do not agree with the post’s title. I am not American but my life and in fact all of our lives have been influenced by America & her policies. I admit that some of her methods, over the years have not been the best (we all can admit to this). But that is no reason to charge the USA with murder because there is a good and bad side to every situation and also we are in charge of our faculties – mental, physical etc. The soldier whether mentally unstabe or not decided to do what he did. In fact I never really understood the Lawyer’s weapon – pleading insanity cause it absolves the defendant, which is not the truth, if the evidence points to him/her! In my country there is a high level of crime but whom must we blame for this? The Government, the police force, the families, the church, the criminal, the educatonal system, financial institutions, Which one? In my mind it is a combination of these influences who’ve caused the citizen to turn to a life of crime. So too this soldier. He has been influenced by his experiences so he chose to do this, not America so she should not be blamed for his decision.

    • Ladybug94

      Your response was very well put and thank you for your service. As a former military dependent to a career soldier as well as coming from a family where the majority are in the military I can affirm the effects war has on a person. My dad was not the same after
      Viet Nam, however he was still sent to more tours up until his retirement. These soldiers have to be rotated in and out of multiple tours, there are not enough people enlisted to not have to do this and people don’t realize the effect this has when you are still suffering from stress from one tour and haven’t completely dealt with it before being sent over again. PTSD has a stronghold on the mind that people don’t understand if you have not experienced it or have someone close to you experience it. Everyone wants to complain about the photos taken of soldiers with the corspses of terrorist but we need to remember this is a war and war is not nice. It’s not like playing the game battleship, it’s brutal. I’ve also had an uncle die as a result of driving over a mine. I could go on but I won’t I just hope others will be more understanding of what our soldiers go through. Hoooah.

  • QueenOfCastle

    This is a tragic situation but it is a case of murder. If PTSD is being used as his defence than any heinous crime commited by the Taliban can similarly be seen as PTSD. I mean people in Afghanistan are born in war and die in war. The have poor nutrition all their lives. No health services, no R&R. Its a constant hell for them but we will not excuse their atrocities committed against themselves or others. This man also has a shady criminal past that was omitted in this piece. He should fry.

  • Ash

    As a military, we do what we are told to do to the best of our abilities with the resources we are given. You want us to fight multiple wars with an all volunteer force and funding that is being limited? Then you have to accept that things like this will happen. An all volunteer force means repeated deployments for many Service Members. Add that to the fact that treating TBI and PTSD is very expensive, and there is a recipe for disaster. I think it’s actually amazing we do as well as we do considering the situation.

    • QueenOfCastle


      I remember watching an episode of People’s Court and apart of the plantiff’s case was that she has been warned by the defendant that her brother in law, who completed a few tours in Iraq, would react violently toward her son was was half Arab and white. And that her son should be kept away from him at all times. While I take mental illness very seriously some people use it as a justification for their anti social behavior.

    • @queenofcastle antisocial behavior is illness. An early stage of psychosis just like some have mild diabetes. Fact. Native Americans had no jail s. Proof that proper social conditions prevent crime. Rome is corrupt to the core and will collapse. History is not to be ignored without dire results. Will we learn and make the necessary changes or will we like Nero just play our violin while Rome burns.

    • Ash

      @QoC No, mental illness is not an excuse for crimes, but it can be a huge mitigating factor when deciding punishment. I can’t see SSG Bales getting the death penalty with his issues; more like life without parole. It just irks me because articles like this make the lot of us seem like murderous, psycho thugs. This guy knew right from wrong to some extent.

      I really do think civilians fail to see the role they play in all of this. Dumb voters are responsible for a lot of the issues we have going on. An all volunteer military was never meant to fight a war (or wars) as we are now.

  • LemonNLime

    “Yet the real guilty parties, our imperialistic government who feels that it’s perfectly normal to murder presidents of sovereign nations in clandestine night raids, bomb schools for Down Syndrome and send drones to blindly massacre innocent children in the “name of war,” continue to make poetic speeches about “progress.””

    I completely agree.

  • TAE

    Touchy subject, very touchy subject. I come from a military family, grew up in a military town Fayetteville, NC, but I would never volunteer to join the armed forces. I’ve seen things and heard things that assure me the military is not the place for me. My family has tried and I’ve resisted, caught a lot of flack for it too but oh well. I greatly respect those brave and dedicated souls who serve our country but I find it hard to respect the government that employs them and the methods by which they believe peace should be achieved. That’s all I have to say about that.