bio_option2_0

“The black man in America is the most copied man on this planet, bar none.”
Paul Mooney

“So is the Black woman.”
Me

Like many, my engagement with what I dub the “Fitness Community” has been more than slightly sporadic over the past decade. Though my love for physical activity has seldom waned, my official participation in the large, fanatical subgroup of fitness enthusiasts exclusively depends on my willingness to engage with the latest (and “greatest”) trend the community has to offer. The past couple years have been waning ones, my interest dwindling right about the time P90X’s frenzied cousin Insanity came onto the scene. But I’ve kept a careful eye on things.

Folks, I am getting concerned. I think it’s time we had a talk -– about butts.

I came into diet culture and fitness in the Britney-era. I recall my most-favored issue of Seventeen magazine that included a single-page schedule packed with crunches, bicycle twists, hip raises, and cardio, all (it claimed) that was needed to achieve the now-iconic “I’m A Slave”-era torso.

While America engaged in some brief flirtation with J.Lo’s rear end and “Bootylicious” sat cozily on the Billboard Top 100, early 00s was all about the abs. P!nk, Christina, Shakira, and the new millennium Janet swiveled and torqued their tightly toned tummies into America’s mushy core.

A decade later, Kim Kardashian West’s couture-covered curves supplanted the wrought-iron abs of Britney & Co. as the media’s latest bodily obsession with the Fitness Community reacting in kind. Even casual gym goers have surely noticed the community becoming rather… ass focused of late. Squats are the new crunches, the Stairmaster has a waiting list 10-people deep, and fitness gurus have morphed from belly fat melting masters to ass authoritarians.

This is all quite grand. As a powerlifter, I consider squats a bread and butter exercise, even more so than the two other competition lifts: bench press and deadlift. Whatever has those who are capable of setting aside the endless sit-ups in favor of an exercise with practical value — be it a squat, lunge, row, or press — earns a tentative thumbs up from me. Never mind that all these born-again lower body builders might vacate soon enough in chase of the next body part in focus. I myself would have never entered the weight room had (my frustration with) P90X never propelled me toward the power rack and the platform.

(Yes, there is a rather large “but” up ahead.)

Like its predecessors, this latest fitness obsession relies on a certain accepted policing of women’s bodies, whereby the gatekeepers of All Things Fit & Toned ™ determine from a limited range of options who and what qualifies as an aesthetically athletic physique, leaving everybody else to the Sisyphean pursuit of this flighty standard (with social consequences accompanying refusal of the task). Hashtags like #justsquat, #shesquatsbro, #squatbooty, and #humpday (yes, those humps) thrive on Instagram and Twitter, while squat challenges of all kinds fill personal Pinterest boards. All across social media can be found the image so familiar as to be blasé: the faceless spandex-clad individual, booty first, reminding without words, “Isn’t it about time you started squatting?”

This hasn’t, however, excluded women from capitalizing on the shift. Jen Selter’s Instagram, while a dubious representation of the traditional tenets of all-around physical fitness (flexibility, strength, endurance), has accrued upwards of 4.4 million followers thanks to gratuitous selfies featuring the fitness model’s lower half. Others with a more modest following, from bikini competitors to casual fitness enthusiasts, have similarly leveraged the prototypical butt selfie into a sizeable follower count and client base.

For those already in possession of the asset at hand, the conclusive message is promising: If you got it, snap what your mama gave ya.

(And, here it comes.)

*But, exclusions apply. This is not the big girl’s time to reign. Fat women who thought the beauty standard had for once been turned in their favor, find disappointment yet again. While allotting some wiggle room for the measurements in particular, the aforementioned gatekeepers are staunchly committed to the hourglass. In the immortal lyrics of Sir Mix-A-Lot, “’Cause your waist is small and your curves are kickin’.”

That the now-throwback hit encapsulates the current figure enforced by the Fitness Community so well seemingly belies any claim to this trend’s distinctness. “Baby Got Back” is over 20 years old and its Billboard success must indicate a message that resonated for listeners in its time. And yet, perhaps daring America to prove him wrong, Mix-A-Lot’s lyrics call out a mainstream that doesn’t take asses as seriously as he does.

I’m tired of magazines / sayin’ flat butts are the thing

So I’m lookin’ at rock videos / Knock-knee’d bimbos walkin’ like hoes

So Cosmo says you’re fat / Well I ain’t down with that

To the beanpole dames in the magazines / “You ain’t it, Miss Thing!”

“Baby Got Back” catalogs cognizance of a cultural split in standards of physical attractiveness. As white America eschewed dietary fat and resistance training to pursue the depleted splendor of heroin chic, Black America would continue to revere a (circumscribed) voluptuous figure.

(Not to give Mix-A-Lot too much credit, here. “Baby Got Back” is explicitly about the sexual preference of one body type over another, with a music video that includes — amongst the expected video vixen dancers — mountainous disembodied asses. Hardly a dream vision of Black women empowerment.)

“Baby Got Back” begins with a monologue delivered in a thick Valley Girl accent (à la “Clueless,” if the movie had been released four years earlier), an exaggerated inflection that effectively races the speaker as white. And in the music video the scene is indeed mimed by two white women (the speaker and “Becky”) while scrutinizing the figure of an anonymous Black woman. The two are fascinated by the woman’s rear end and continue to stare as the speaker struggles to comprehend and articulate its existence. It’s “so big,” she tries at first. “[The woman] looks like one of those rap guys’ girlfriends,” she attempts next, as if the relegation to some sort of cultural niche explains the size and shape of the woman’s posterior. But still, “it’s just so big”! It’s “round,” it’s “out there,” it’s “gross.” Finally, the speaker lands on qualifier so sought, “She’s just so… black.”

1 2 
Tags: , ,
Like Us On Facebook Follow Us On Twitter
  • MimiLuvs

    This is my second time reading this XOJane post (the first time was from off of XOJane site) and I still find it to be all over the place.

    Once I was able to figure out the gist of this article, my initial reaction to it was “And water is wet”. I understand her gripe and she has the right to vent. But I am tired of reading articles (or hearing about articles) in which a writer portrays herself as being surprised of a culture vulture’s actions.

    The XOJane readers’ comments were typical: less than 50 comments attached to the article.

  • Primmest Plum

    These xoJane reticules always feel so vapid and obvious.